The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 6 · June 1902
313printed page
scan 19 of 68
Facsimile · scan 19 of 68
Scan of p. 313
Text · transcribed from the scan

minate Palestine from their philanthropic propaganda, just so long will they labor in vain towards perfecting an organization for the amelioration of the condition of the Russian and Roumanian Jews. An organiztion which really ought to contain within its ranks every Jew, rich or poor, who has compassion for the suffering of his coreligionists." We really cannot be "all things to all men," even to win their support. The play without Hamlet would be as nothing to Zionism ignoring Palestine.

NEWSPAPER VIEWS.

THE Jewish Voice, of San Francisco, offers us a suggestion which though it comes to hand too late to be acted upon this year may be borne in mind in the future. Says the Voice:

Benevolence and mutual helpfulness are tendencies claimed for the Federation of American Zionists which, in our eyes, give them a raison d'etre, making us forgetful of the visionary plans underlying the whole movement. We accept the good even in the unacceptable garb, and look upon the utilitarian part as the main incentive for the active support solicited. From this point of view we regretted the total absence of representation of the Zionists from the Charity Conference recently held in Detroit. The immediate and pressing need of work proposed in the removal of large numbers of our coreligionists from the terribly congested districts of the Ghetto, particularly in New York, should appeal to the American Federation of Zionists with even greater force than to any other organization, and we confidently expected to see the Conference turning its full face towards the Federation, both of whom might work hand in hand in this great and urgent cause. Why was there no representation?

If the Voice had a better appreciation of Zionism it would realize that our first duty as Zionists is to perfect our organization before we venture upon tasks which though they have our fullest sympathy are local in their objectivity. Nevertheless if there is a call issued for the aid of organized Zionism in the settlement of New York problems the Zionists will not be found wanting.

AN ADMISSION.

THE Rev. J. H. Landau, an Australian Jewish Rabbi, has committed to the Jewish Herald some "random thoughts of an anti-Zionist." At the outset, he says: "I am not one who would wish to brush away such a movement as this with a sneer and a jest. Whatever our opinions may be, we must be fundamentally grateful, in one respect at least to the leaders of the Zionistic

unrest. They have at last proposed some serious matter for us to think about. They have given us a sharpened appetite for sturdier nutrition than that dished out to us by the common rationalism, the presumptious liberalism, the foolish and utterly reprehensible radicalism of the ordinary kind, so rampant and so arrogant in these later days in Judaism. They have awakened anew the slumbering ideal of 2,000 years in a people credited only with aims both sordid and grasping."

This admision fully counterbalances his random thoughts on Zionism. Besides the stock objections which have grown more than thin through use, he adds one suggestion which, too, is an admission; for he says, “To test the world’s attitude toward’s Israel, another thousand year’s history is needed to swell the record.” What an exceedingly comfortable attitude for someone living under the freedon of Australian rule. Being human, Dr. Landau will not have to suffer the test for ten centuries. But in all honesty, if he is such an admirer of the martyr’s pose, he should hie himself to those lands in which as a mere Jew, he can suffer persecution. We do not wish to sentence him for life; we believe even less than a decade would persuade him that the philosopher of the. study indulges in a cheap sophism when he advises the sufferer to go on suffering for the benefit of remote posterity.

CORRESPONDENCE.

S. Y. (New York) writes : You will confer a great favor on an ardent Zionist as well upon a prominent society and, no doubt, upon many others if you will inform me of the relations of Mr. S. Jarmulowsky of Canal St. to the Federation and the Jewish Colonial Trust Ltd.

Mr. S. Jarmulowsky is the authorized agent in the United States for the J. C. T. and all shares sold through his office go to the credit of the general operations of the Federation of American Zionists. We may here mention that the movement is considerably indebted to Mr. Jarmulowsky for he not only guards the interests of the Trust thoroughly as a business man but he has for three years given and will continue to give the use of his office free to the Trust without receiving or claiming the slightest compensation for the trouble he is put to; transferring to the Trust every penny he receives for Trust shares from subscribers. [Ed. M.]