The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 6 · June 1902
308printed page
scan 14 of 68
Facsimile · scan 14 of 68
Scan of p. 308
Text · transcribed from the scan

But this view of Zionism does not meet the approval of many of our adherents. The majority of Zionists take such a material, business-like view of our movement, that it almost chills the heart of those who are accustomed to associate with the name “Zion” everything that is holy and ideal. To these so called practical Zionists, the Jews have a natural right to live and be happy, and since this right is being denied to them in the lands of their captivity, it is but reasonable that they should seek to form a political center of their own in order to be secure in their worldly pursuits. These advocates of self-preservation, in their strong desire to improve the material condition of their brethren, repudiate strongly the theory of a Jewish mission, and are loudest in their denunciation of it as a shamming scheme of our Reformed Rabbis to injure the cause of Zionism. They seek in this movement a remedy for the economical miseries of our people, and they deny that we owe to the world any moral obligations. They say that the Jew need not teach nor be taught. He is not better nor worse than the rest of the world. He is not obliged to suffer to benefit others. He is disliked in strange lands, then he must retire to his own land and be independent.

This is their line of reasoning, and we must admit that from their standpoint they are right. If the Jews had no other aim in life but their own material welfare, then they were justified in concentrating all their energies, upon obtaining Palestine as soon as possible, without regard as to whether the Jews are morally capable of establishing a modern commonwealth. But the idea of a Jewish mission to the world is not the monopoly of the Reformed Rabbis. There are a number of Zionists who equally believe that our people are burdened with a message to the world, and these Zionists would never support Zionism if they did not consider it an effective instrument by which to transmit that message.

It may, however, be interesting, first to notice how the idea of a Jewish mission is arrived at. It is maintained by its advocates, that when the Jews were banished from their land, it was not as a punishment for their national transgressions but it was rather a contemplated act of Providence with a great and noble end in view. The Jews were predestined to wander throughout the world and preach the truth of God. Therefore He has taken them out from Egyptian slavery and brought them into the land of Canaan. There they dwelt for fifteen hundred years, during which time they were brought nearer to God.

Palestine was the school where the world's teachers were trained, and not until they were thoroughly fit to officiate as such, were they allowed to take their position in the world. They were selected to be a “Kingdom of priests,” and priests, under the Biblical law, had no right to own any land. Priests, however, had no right to sit in some obscure corner of the world and enjoy life, while corruption and injustice prevailed everywhere. Out into the large world they had to go and start their missionary work; the work of planting the seeds of truth and morality. And they did go from land to land, from continent to cont nent, preaching that Law that was given to them amidst thunder and lightning. and never for a moment did they hesitate in raising their voice in opposition to evil and mischief. They knew and understood their mission, and therefore ignored all physical pain and torture inflicted upon them by their enemies. They did not expect any reward, they cared not for recognition, they were perfectly happy to suffer for the truth, and they never thought of giving up their work until they shall have succeeded in establishing among men the true love of brotherhood.

Now the question is, have we a right for personal reasons only, to desert our camp and discontinue our holy work, and run back to the land of our fathers? Have we accomplished the work assigned to us by God? Has the world recognized all the truths contained in our Bible? Is there no more oppression, no more tyranny to oppose? Are there no more woes, no more sorrows to sooth ? Have men reached the zenith of civilization, and is there nothing more in our Law that we can teach ? How dare we go back to our home before we have carried out our duties? Was it for this that Providence has preserved us through centuries of persecution, to bring us back to our land and let us exist as a small and insignificant nation? We complain of our sufferings and say we cannot endure any longer the misery and humiliation in exile; but havenot our fathers suffered much more and still they never thought of freeing themselves from their sufferings by giving up their missionary work ?

The reformers say that for these reasons we have no right to desert our camp and go back to Palestine. We Zionists, however, maintain that because of these reasons we must strive to form a political center of our own. We acknowledged the fact that our ancestors, during the eighteen hundred years of our dispersion, have accomplished much in the line of acquainting the world