The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 5 · May 1902
268printed page
scan 28 of 54

Suddenly the chairman of the meeting arose — the same young referee who, on the occasion of the formation of the German Hilfsverein, injured the cause of Zionism by his unseemly conduct—and asked the speaker how long his speech was to last. Vogelstein answered that he did not know, and that in any case he did not need to tell, as it was unparliamentary to interrupt a speaker in that way. The chairman answered : ‘You only wish to make discussion impossible by your long speech.’ Dr. Vogelstein then left the hall with the words, ‘Whoever agrees with me in disapproving of such behavior, and holds it to be incompatible with decency and good form, let him follow me and leave this place with me.’ Naturally, both Zionists and non-Zionists followed him. Thus the cause of Zionism was again what suffered through the whole affair.’’

The MONTREAL ZIONIST Society

The annual meeting of the Montreal ZionistSociety took place on the 11th of April, in EmpireHall. Mr. Jacob Cohen, the President of theSociety, occupied the chair. Mr. Clarence I. deSola, President of the Federation of Zionist Societies of Canada, was present, and addressedthe Society on the progress made by the Zionistmovement generally during the past year. Onmotion of Mr. H. Bernstein, a substantial sumwas voted in support of the National Fund. Onmotion of David A. Hart it was resolved to permit youths to become affiliated with the Society,and a number of names was thereby added to themembership. An appeal was made for subscriptions to 'The Maccabæan, and steps weretaken to secure the full support of the membersof the Society to that publication. A committeewas appointed to arrange for the acquisition ofnew meeting rooms, in which a library and reading room shall be maintained. The election ofofficers was then proceeded with, and resulted asfollows :—President, Dr. David A. Hart; FirstVice-President, Mr. J. S. Leo; Second Vice-Pre-sident, Mr. M. Schapiro ; Treasurer, Mr. IsraelRubenstein ; Corresponding Secretary, Mr. H.Weirfield; Recording Secretary, Mr. WilliamLevi; Hebrew Secretary, Mr. S. Talpis.

AMERICAN JEWS IN RUSSIA.

The following is the text of the resolution which Mr. Goldfogle introduced in the House of Representatives:

Resolved, That the Secretary of State be and he

hereby is, directed to inform this House whether American citizens of the Jewish religion, holding passports issued by this Government, are barred or excluded from entering the territory of the Empire of Russia, and whether the Russian Government has made, or is making, any discrimination between citizens of the United States of different religious faith or persuasion, visiting or attempting to visit Russia, provided with American passports, and whether the Russian Government has made regulations restricting or specially applying to American citizens, whether native or naturalized, of the Jewish religious denomination, holding United States passports, and if so, to report the facts in relation thereto, and what action concerning such exclusion, discrimination or restriction, if any has been taken by any department of the United States.

The resolution was approved by Congress, and since then Mr. Hay has informed the House that his interpretation of the resolution involves two questions: Whether American Jews holding American passports are, as a fact, excluded from Russia, and whether American Jews are discriminated against by Russia, and are at a greater disadvantage before that government than are the Jews in other countries. To which the Secretary replied that the second question may be answered categorically in the negative; that such a discrimination, if it were made, would call forth immediate action of protest from this Government. Further he said that his department had no information remotely indicating that American Jews stood upon a footing different from that occupied by the Jews of other countries in the administration of Russian law. Since the report made by Secretary Olney, upon the same subject, the position of the Department had not changed and its efforts to secure uniform treatment of American citizens in Russia, begun many years ago, have continued although they have not been attended with encouraging success. Secretary Olney recognized Russia's contention that no Russian could expatriate himself without the consent of his sovereign, but; protested against that notion. The question we would ask, however, and it is generally ignored, is this: What would be done with an American Jew of certain French or English descent, should he desire to enter Russia; would not the same restrictions hamper him?

THE CONVENTION PROGRAM

The Committee, in whose charge all the ar-