The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 5 · May 1902
250printed page
scan 10 of 54
250
THE MACCABÆAN.
[May, 1902.]

Pleas and Records from the Exchequer of the Jews

1220—1284

THE appearance of the work before us is an important event in the history writing of the Jews of England and of Europe generally. It affords most valuable insight into a largely neglected period of Jewish history, and corrects many erroneous ideas about the legal status of the mediaeval Jew, while, on the other hand, corroborating and establishing by uncontrovertible facts, some of the most recently evolved theories as to the legal relations of the Jew to the European state till modern times. The first impression made by a perusal of this work is one of astonishment that such an enormous collection of court records concerning the Jews, dating from such an early and yet brief period, should still be extant. No other country affords such a mass of official records from such an early period, and a study thereof is therefore bound to furnish valuable clues to unravelling European Jewish history in general, as was so well pointed out by Mr. Joseph Jacobs nearly ten years ago in his valuable work on "The Jews of Angevin England." On the other hand, it seems strange that publication of these records has not taken place before this. They did not escape the attention of that arch anti-Semite of Cromwell's day, William Prynne, from whose "Short Demurrer," directly or indirectly, nearly all historians of the Jews of England drew their material for the pre-expulsion period until a decade or so ago. More recently these rich supplies were drawn upon and analyzed and summarized by Prof. Charles Gross in the preparation of his very suggestive and valuable paper upon "The Exchequer of the Jews of England in the Middle Ages," contained in No. 1 of the Publications of the Anglo-Jewish Historical Exhibition, and also by Mr. Joseph Jacobs in his above-cited work, which purports, however, to run down to 1206 only. They were also utilized in a measure in the preparation of a valuable chapter on "The Jews" in "The History of English Law before the time of Edward I" by Frederic Pollock and Prof. F. W. Maitland. Each of these writers emphasized the importance of making these records accessible by their early publication. All students ought to be grateful that this service has now been so well performed by Mr. J. M. Rigg, under the joint auspices of the Jewish Historical Society of England and the Selden Society. The difficulties of deciphering the manuscripts and of translation, identifying persons and places, and preparing the extremely valuable "Introduction" of 61 pages, must have been enormous. Mr. Rigg has gone to his task without bias, and shown considerable independence throughout in rejecting hitherto accepted theories and formulating new ones, in spite of the weight of tradition and authority. "Theorizing" is, however, confined to the "Introduction," which is based upon the "Rolls of the Exchequer of Receipt, John-Edward I." and a heterogeneous assortment of documents, indexed as accounts. This "Introduction" is most valuable, being based on a most painstaking and careful examination of an immense amount of unpublished material, in the light of a thorough knowledge of early English history and early English law. Some of Mr. Rigg's conclusions will be considered more fully hereafter; at present I merely desire to express regret that Mr. Rigg's chapter does not seem to be based upon any thorough consideration of continental works on legal Jewish status, such as the very erudite and valuable work just published by Dr. J. E. Scherer on "Die Rechtsverhaeltnisse der Juden in den Deutsch- Oesterreichischen Laendern." Aside from the value of comparative studies, thus eliminated, it seems quite clear that the legal status of the Jews in early England was evolved, as in other countries, from a superimposition of Teutonic law and feudalism upon the Roman law's provisions concerning the Jews, and much in the legal status of the Jews in England from 1220 to 1284 can be explained only in the light of these facts. This is but another instance going to show that one cannot detach and examine thoroughly any particular section of Jewish history, without being fairly cognizant of general Jewish history, and that, invaluable as a thorough knowledge of English law be for the preparation of such a volume, considerable acquaintanceship with general Jewish history and legal status is also desirable. But Mr. Rigg does not pretend to contribute any general work on the legal status of Jewish residents of England at any particular period, but

by Mr. J. M. Rigg, under the joint auspices of the Jewish Historical Society of England and the Selden Society. The difficulties of deciphering the manuscripts and of translation, identifying persons and places, and preparing the extremely valuable “Introduction” of 61 pages, must have been enormous. Mr. Rigg has gone to his task without bias, and shown considerable independence throughout in rejecting hitherto accepted theories and formulating new ones, in spite of the weight of tradition and authority. “Theorizing” is, however, confined to the “Introduction,” which is based upon the “Rolls of the Exchequer of Receipt, John-Edward I.” and a heterogeneous assortment of documents, indexed as accounts. This “Introduction” is most valuable, being based on a most painstaking and careful examination of an immense amount of unpublished material, in the light of a thorough knowledge of early English history and early English law. Some of Mr. Rigg’s conclusions will be considered more fully hereafter; at present I merely desire to express regret that Mr. Rigg’s chapter does not seem to be based upon any thorough consideration of continental works on legal Jewish status, such as the very erudite and valuable work just published by Dr. J. E. Scherer on “Die Rechtsverhaeltnisse der Juden in den Deutsch-Oesterreichischen Laendern.” Aside from the value of comparative studies, thus eliminated, it seems quite clear that the legal status of the Jews in early England was evolved, as in other countries, from a superimposition of Teutonic law and feudalism upon the Roman law’s provisions concerning the Jews, and much in the legal status of the Jews in England from 1220 to 1284 can be explained only in the light of these facts. This is but another instance going to show that one cannot detach and examine thoroughly any particular section of Jewish history, without being fairly cognizant of general Jewish history, and that, invaluable as a thorough knowledge of English law be for the preparation of such a volume, considerable acquaintanceship with general Jewish history and legal status is also desirable. But Mr. Rigg does not pretend to contribute any general work on the legal status of Jewish residents of England at any particular period, but

*Select Pleas, Starrs and other Records from the Rolls of the Exchequer of the Jews. A. D. 1220-1284. Edited for the Jewish Historical and the Selden Societies by J. M. Rigg, London. Bernard Quaritch 1902, pp. LXII +152.