The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 4 · April 1902
201printed page
scan 15 of 56
April, 1902.
THE MACCABÆAN.
201

and most thorough investigation. At this point questionings into the relation of religion to political and social matters naturally rose to the surface. The subject concerned Judaism more nearly than other religions, because from its origin it has considered and treated these great elements of human existence as integral parts of religion, as necessary consequences of the moral law. The Mosaic and the Talmudic law were only partially treated in an independent scientific spirit (Frankel, Saalschuetz, Samuel Mayer, 1862, 1866), and partially with particular reference to the general questions of state and society (Salvator). Together with these special works went the endeavor to deduct general principles from the laws and institutions of Judaism, especially from Mosaism, and to demonstrate that these laws and institutions are exactly those toward which mankind aspires as its goal, and for whose realization mankind suffers and struggles — an aspiration and a struggle at that time vividly present as a persistent impelling force. It was to be proven that these principles, as the consequences of the doctrine of the oneness of God, of the oneness of the world, and of the oneness of mankind; and expressing themselves in the unification of all human races into a family, in the equality and personal freedom of individuals, in a certain levelling of private ownership, by which the right to personal prosperity is regarded, but is harmonized with the needs of the state;—it is to be proven, that these principles are the principles of Mosaism as enunciated in its laws and embodied in its institutions, and as they are to be realized in a time of general peace, in a time of the universal dominion of love and law. It is obvious that this great question of principle was, perforce, but one part of the primary question regarding the historic mission of Judaism. For both issues Philippsohn's lectures, on the development of religious ideas in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam (1847), and on the religion of society (1848), did pioneer work. Unfortunately this hobby of “principles” was ridden too hard. The effort was made to prove

that a particularistic natural Judaism and 'the idea of the universal brotherhood of man were mutually exclusive. Such an opposition. however, does not exist, for the reason that a strong national culture is the very basis of a healthy, rational state of peace among nations.. The one does not exclude the other ; the one presupposes the other. An assumption of principles, which would leave the national idea without safeguards, and which would not concern itself with the maintenance of the national character, would be phantastic, impossible, chimerical—a mission to be realized in timeless eternity, in boundless space.

It was a fashionable fad of the day. Good intentions, but lack of self-consciousness and of strength of pride, drove the men of the time to a lane of mist and fog, and forced them to climb to heights of rarefied air. Instead of showing the soberness and strength of purpose, the earnestness and dignity to banish despondency and to knit the bond of national feeling, instead of fostering the sense of individuality, of national sincerity and naivete, they stuck their national feeling deep down in their bosoms, and developed a hollow phraseology. They did not lack talent or good will, but courage. They always dropped into into preaching, and struck the hackneyed attitude of self-abnegation; they practised pitifully small arts of diplomacy to win the favor of the ""nations""; they were filled with a yearning for an apostolic world-mission, awaited with loathing naivete in the near future; they gave utterance to tiresome, often absurd commonplaces about the brotherhood of man, without understanding that the very way to community is through segregation. They failed to see that in considering a distant ideal one must remember Goethe's warning not to try to hasten a fruit into ripeness by holding a lamp under it.

(To be continued.)

N. SOKOLOW.

[Translated by Adele Szold.]