The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 4 · April 1902
199printed page
scan 13 of 56

tion of the essence of an object, of its origin,genesis, development, continuance, and activity; of the vital connection of cause and effect;of its essential principle, and the emanations andthe embodiment of the principle; finally, of itsaims, its means, and its realization. It is se!f-evident that science implies thorough knowledgeof the subject; the most complete mastery of thematerial; it implies the exercise of criticism andsystematic elaboration. Upon this as a foundation is raised the real structure of science, including knowledge of an organism in its entirety, inall its parts, in all its historic manifestationsand creations, and as it has realized and continues to realize itself. Thus, "science of Judaism"is a legitimate concept. It will express itselfpartly in the scientific history of Judaism, partlyin the scientific elaboration of its ideal content,which manifests itself in the inner life of thepeople as well as in external forms and actualproducts.

It has been asserted that the science of Judaism is of recent origin ; in point of fact, it is not young ; it has already past through several eras. In making this statement I do not reckon the religio-philosophic works of Philo the Alexandrian or of Saadia; for mere religio-philosophic treatment is not science. But when we come to Maimonides, we have reached one of the founders of Jewish science. His great personality, uniting in itself the most strongly accentuated and the most remarkable characteristics of the Jewish genius, was epoch-making. He was too thoroughgoing a disciple of Aristotle, the founder of all sciences, not to follow the example of his master. He could not but conceive of Judaism as a science, and treat it as such. Besides giving a religio-philosophic presentation of the entire content of Judaism, he systematically arranged Jewish doctrines and the Jewish law in its Mosaic and its traditional forms ; he tried to explain the aim and meaning of both doctrine and law, and endeavored to determine their formation by the historical method. His work, however, remained only an attempt; we know that the historical method in his time must perforce have been inadequate.

It is true that to a greater or less extent the historical method was employed by a number of writers. To prove the fact it would be necessary only to point to the many learned thinkers and their valuable treatises. In this place we can do no more than touch upon the intelligence and capacity for work developed by the representatives of Jewish learning before the beginning of the

nineteenth century. The “Meor Enaim” of Azariah di Rossi is an intellectual product of the first rank. The remarkably penetrating insight into the source of things displayed by R. Elia of Wilna in all his works bore, in a measure, the impress of our almost scientific method of research. Yet the instances of the use of this method are isolated. For this reason, it is pardonable to consider the science of Judaism specifically a product of the 19th century. It began with the consciousness that, in order to ensure Judaism a higher significance in our times, and thus, a permanent existence, it is necessary to study it as a science. The three numbers of Zunz’s “Zeitschrift fuer die Wissenschaft des Judenthums” (1822-1823) illustrate the attempts made to apply this method in the investigation of specific subjects. From this time the history of Judaism, being a highly important portion of the science of Judaism, received the most comprehensive treatment, both as a study of Judaism itself and of the Jewish people. There appeared the historical work of Jost, “Geschichte der Israeliten seit der Zeit der Makkabaer” (1820-1828), his “Allgemeine Geschichte des Juedischen Volkes” (1831-1832), his “Neue Geschichte der Israeliten von 1815-1845” (1847) and his “Geschichte des Judenthums” (1857-1859). And the same time appeared Zunz’s “Die Gottesdienstlichen Vortraege der Juden, historisch entwickelt” (Berlin 1832), a pioneer work establishing the scientific methods for Jewish research. It was followed by his literary-historic works on synagogal poetry, the last of which appeared in 1865. Their disciples keeping an onward course, did not lack capable activity; they expanded the work of their predecessors, rectified it, and broadened it in conception. The works of Herzfeld, “Geschichte des Volkes Israel von der Zerstoerung des ersten Tempels bis zur Einsetzung des Makkabaers Schimeon zum Hohenpriester und Fuersten” (Brunswick, 1847-1857), Graetz (1853-1869), Fuerst, “Geschichte des Karaerthums” (1862-1865), the works of Geiger, Steinschneider, Frankel, Munk, Dukes, and others, in addition to a great number of special histories, bear ample witness to the strong historic consciousness penetrating the minds of modern Jews, and ever impelling them to the true realization of scientific ideals that is to be allowed not only in a critical illumination of facts, but in a deep and clear understanding of all historic manifestations. In this way roads were opened up leading to the investigation and exposition of the history of Judaism, including the