unless we, their more fortunate brethren, can come to their rescue, and make or find for them some spot on earth which they can call a home. Read Mr. Greenberg's report of the conditions in England, the most favored home of Judaism, in a sense, and yet where the “wildest outcry,” he says, is being raised against the “alien invaders” — a mere handful, as Mr. Greenberg tells us, “but rendering the Jewish problem that confronts the Jews in England all the more grave.” And note this significant phrase: “For here we have a people who besides, like other immigrants, introducing new methods and to some extent new branches of trade, unlike all other immigrants, do not merge with the general population.”
ee But we need not go abroad for our facts. Look nearer home, in our very midst, on the East Side — see the frightful conditions, the tenements crowded and packed with vice, so that all New York stood aghast at the appalling revelations. What vestige of the ancient faith remains, of the ancient purity of life and habits, when the bulwarks fall, and the fatal plunge is made from the routine of custom or superstition to sordid, brutal and brutalizing materialism. As Dr. Herzl truly says : ““ The discovery of America has come too late. America has already her problem of Jewish misery,’” and we may add, unfaith.
Can we then, in contrast, point with complacent and self-satisfied pride to the upper crust of Jewish American Society? Do we not very well know that we ourselves, the privileged ones, are only tolerated, and only sure of the footing we hold, on condition that we restrict, and keep carefully within bounds, this alien immigration; in other words, that we shut our gates, and close our harbors against these, our outcast brethren, to whom we are bound by a race-tie deep-rooted, and old as time and fate — a tie closer than any we are permitted to make with the people around us, who share perhaps our daily, intimate life. How then can we deny or disguise the facts? Anti-Semitism lurks and smoulders every where. And why? Because Jews are Jews the world over, and in whatsoever rank or walk of life we find them — whether at the top or bottom of the scale, whether among the too rich who have the world in their grip, as anti-Semitism declares, or the too poor, who go to swell the ranks of the malcontents, the enemies of society; whether they are counted too clever or too ignorant, the foremost or too hindmost in the race, and the desperate struggle for existence; it matters not —
one and all, they are under the same condemnation. They are Jews and Jews they will remain not alone, or even chiefly because the Christians wish it, but because we ourselves will have it so, as long as we cherish and cling to our race-her-itage, and continue to be members of a race that never has coalesced, and that never will coalesce, however loudly we may proclaim our patriotism for the country of our birth, because necessarily from this racial point of view, to merge becomes a crime, and intermarriage, suicide. We may wait till the end of time, but the paradox only grows greater in proportion to the growth of enlightenment within and around us; all barriers seem to have broken down, but an invisible one remains, and the Jews have not become Christians, nor the Christians, Jews, for they move along parallel lines that cannot meet. On a purely spiritual basis, nations do not grow and knit together. We may tolerate and be tolerated, or we may look askance upon one another; we cannot really love and be loved unless we are free to merge and be merged in the community of which we form a part.
Zionism cannot solve all of our problems, although it is by far the largest and most comprehensive, the most liberating answer that has yet been given. Even if we should never be able to attain our goal, the very energy with which we have set about to overmaster “ insurmountable ”’ obstacles, is an inspiration and emancipation in itself, a ““heartening” of our people, and a strengthening of the whole fibre of the nation. Not all Jews can or should go to Palestine, but for those who remain in the countries of their adoption, the strain will be lightened, and the difficulties lessened. They will no longer carry the weight and burden of their whole race, and can more freely work out their individual salvation according to the light that is in them. At least their position will no longer be a false one, and they willknow how to take the full consequences and responsibility of it.
And as to our Zionism, if we would make a success of it, we must put it on a large and broad and free basis. We must beware of labels—political, sociological, humanitarian, or even spiritual Zionism. If weare to be a nation we must be composed of varied elements, and embrace everytype. We must also beware of a narrow sectarianism, the old schisms of orthodoxy and reform, the petty restrictions and exclusions which have always been the reproach of the Jew, even while he has boasted most loudly of his larger and universal truth. Otherwise he will not give