The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 3 · March 1902
160printed page
scan 28 of 56

will demand that the influx of the Jew at once cease."

“ Let them have Palestine in readiness for that unhappy day.” Mr. Greenberg advised. “ The Jewish emigration from Eastern Europe during the last twenty years has been something like six or seven hundred thousands- Now if this influx had gone to Palestine instead of to America and England, Eastern Europe and the New World would have had no ground for complaint, nor would England have had the slightest provocation for an Alien Immigration Bill. The question is often put: Who would we get to found the Palestinean state? Well,” answered Mr. Greenberg, “ we would not expect the prosperous Jewish business man to leave his home — Zionism was never intended to touch him. But what we do anticipate are the thousands of Russian and Polish Jews always emigrating from the Czar’s possessions and who in the past have given to England and America the majority of its now well-to-do Jewish traders and workmen. At least we would have this advantage over, say, Australia,” said Mr. Greenberg in reply to my objection that “ only the scum of the Jews would go to Palestine,” “ that the original inhabitants would not be transported convicts ! ”

Mr. Greenberg's concluding remarks were a return to the Alien Immigration problem. "The crux of the whole question," he said, "lays in the extreme possibility of the Jewish immigrant with all his natural advantages bringing about a larger predominance of Jewish influence than this country is prepared to allow, and so arranging the prelude perhaps to the final struggle for Jewish emancipation in this country. Immigration, it has yet to be shown. and particularly in regard to the Jewish proportion, has been other than beneficial to this country."

In a letter addressed to a recent gathering of London Zionist, Mr. Hall Caine, the novelist, wrote: “Time was when no restrictions were put upon those who fled from poverty or tyranny to the protection of our shores ; when no one asked if they were German or Italian, Russian or Pole, maimed or whole, sick or well, or what other countries were doing with their foreign exiles. In those days it was the glory of England that she was, above all other lands, the land of liberty, the sanctuary of Europe, the city of refuge for God’s refugees, And England had her reward. In doing what was right to the refugees, she

also did what was best for herself, and she became the most prosperous as well as the most beloved empire on earth. God forbid that at the call of a short-sighted commercialism, a bad political economy and a false national spirit, we should go back on the principles which have made England great and free.”

It will be recalled that at the Second International Zionist Congress M. Cesare Lombroso, the celebrated criminologist and anthropologist, sent a letter to Dr. Herzl in which he stated that he regretted his inability to be present to assist in the deliberations of the Congress. In a recent interview, which took place at Amsterdam upon his return from the International Congress of Anthropologists, M. Lombroso is reported to have said :

"I am a Zionist because I am a Jew, and as a Jew it is impossible not to be a Zionist. I believe in the revival of the Jewish nation, of our national power. When Dr. Herzl and Dr. Nordau, who are personal friends of mine, declare that it is possible in a short time to place our people in our own country, it is no dream they speak of, but a reality. If our rich men would only open their coffers I am sure that their plans would soon be realized. say in two years. But our Jewish capitalists will never consent to give their money to a cause the initiators of which were some poor journalists. But what fills one with the conviction of success, is the thought that that which the people do for themselves is always permanent and more durable than that which is done for them by others."

In his admirable sketch of the late M. Jean de Bloch, published in "The Jewish Chronicle" and "Die, Welt," Mr. N. Sokolow writes the following on his attitude toward Zionism:

"In his very last years J. G. Bloch's interestwas enlisted on behalf of the Zionist idea. Frombeing sceptical and hypercritical, his sympathieswere at last given a powerful impetus. Unhappily too late ! Death surprised him in the middleof the work he had begun. The weaknesses ofassimilation will not be attributed to the son ofthe Lomza dyer in his grave. Thus are webereft of strength. So without leaving a tracebehind, vanishes what the potential energy ofthe Jewish race, accumulated through a thousand years, what Jewish industry had built up,so does it all vanish through want of a nationalfoundation. In spite of his assimilation he wasthe best of half Jews : a penetrating Jewishmind, a warm Jewish heart, a practical geniusand a poet. Thus does a generation die, thus