Alien Immigration in England
The following account of an interesting discussion of the Immigration question of which Mr. L. J. Greenberg, a capable Zionist, is one of the most ardent opponents, is taken from the Manchester (England) "Evening Chronicle."
Mr. L. J. Greenberg of London put it to the writer yesterday that if the poor persecuted Jews of Russia, Roumania and Galicia kept on coming to England, the possibility was that there would be considerable trouble.
Mr. Greenberg said: “Of course a deal of misunderstanding exists on the subject, and figures may be usefully employed to indicate exactly how the Jew stands here in England in relation to the general population. In 1880 the Jews numbered something like 70,000. By natural increase this would have been raised to-day to 90,000, allowing that is about 5 per cent, more than the ordinary ratio of increase in view of the small death-rate and high birth-rate amongst the Jews. However, instead of this being the case, the number has increased by 90,000, so that in England to-day there are 160,000 Jews. Thus, excepting the children born of immigrants, the augmentation mentioned has been due to immigration. It may seem large, but within a comparatively small period 500,000 Russian and Polish Jews have emigrated to America—a proof of the manner in which they work the restrictive laws there. But these people, mind you, are no poverty-stricken aliens, becoming at once charge on poor law authorities, but able workmen, who quickly find employment and add to the commercial prosperity of the country. Although, so far as I am concerned, I consider the immigration of Jews in this country a distinct benefit, I do not wish to persuade myself that English people, any more than others, can digest an abnormal immigration. Consequently, we are face to face in England, as elsewhere, as Jews, with the Jewish problem in all its disturbing features. There are eleven million Jews in the world, more than three-fourths of whom are living in a state little better than that of beasts. In Russia the Jew is necessarily kept down because otherwise he would easily outstrip the dull-headed moujik, and there is very little hope of the conditions being reversed there. The inevitable result is that the Jew physically and morally is being forcibly degenerated.”
"Is it any wonder, therefore, that he sees in immigration the only means of salvation. England is getting rather full, and American Jews have already sent the significant message over here that no more Jews must be dispatched thither."
“Can anything be done to improve matters?” the writer asked.
"Yes," was the reply. "The means are now at hand, and require to be taken advantage of — 'Zionism!' What the movement would do if it were only consummated would be to divert the stream of immigration from Europe and America to Palestine. The Jewish question in the Western states would be immediately relieved. But if the Jews do go to Palestine," was added in parenthesis, "they must proceed in full recognition by the world of their rights as Jews, not as Outlanders. Given once this state, and the status of the Jew all over the world would be improved. Look at Holland, only a little kingdom, but how respected its people are. It would be the same with the Jews—experience teaches us it is so."
Mr. Greenberg proceeded to discuss what he termed the anomaly of the Jew. “The Jews,” he explained, “are a separate and distinct entity from the rest of the people. It is an anomaly for a Jew to term himself either a Frenchman, Englishman, or German — nationally and religiously he is simply a Jew, and no matter how he may seek to blind his eye to the fact, he is bound to admit it in the end. The English Legislature to-morrow could turn out every Jew, but could not turn out every Englishman, for that would be ridiculous. Therefore, for the Jew to ‘I will assimilate and become an Englishman’ is the height of absurdity. He cannot obliterate his Jewish nationality. People have looked upon the Jew with much the same feeling as we regard a black man — somebody not one of ourselves. At the present day the Jewish workman has become wedged in the commercial life of this country almost indistinguishably. Yet if his number were to be appreciably increased there would be a deal of murmuring and cries that the Jew was becoming too influential. And this would happen whether he remained a Jew or became a fully fledged Englishman. Matters are all right just now, and there is little fear of the proposed Aliens Immigration Bill becoming law, but the Jewish community should take the warning in time and be prepared, if it ever does come to pass, for the time when the British workman