J.C.A. was still earnestly at work trying to place them here and there. But these Roumanians were not beggars; they were men with crafts and trades. They were the very labor force which was so desirable in new colonies. Why, some were now developing the coal and iron mines of Cape Breton and Newfoundland. Had the Hirsch millions been profitably. employed, these Roumanians, instead of being received with consternation, would have been welcomed, a Jewish colony would have been ready to receive them. Two years ago the J.C.A. took over the Palestinean Colonies. They did not hear then how illegal itwasto employ the Hirsch Fund in Palestine. Mr. Montefiore referred him to the Statutes. Ifthe Hirsch millions could not legally be employed for Zionism, half of his case would fallto the ground. Dr. Gaster deprecated acrimonious discussion. But argument was not acrimony. Dr. Gaster asked how dare one Jew accuse another? How dare Jews who take part in public life demand to be exempt from criticism —they might miscall it accusation — from other Jews ? One of the worst features of living a life apart from the rest of thecommunity and being subjected to its hostile criticism was that the ‘Jewish writer dare not frankly describe his people’s failings; for they would cry out: “ Do not foul your own nest, do not give us away to the goyim.”’ Ifthey read the novels of Dickens or Thackeray they would find they were nothing but a long satire upon English life, they were full of rogues, clerical and lay, of swindlers, Scape-graces, adventurers, even murderers; they poured scorn upon the most cherished features of their country’s life, they taught a people to know itself. The Jews of England having always to live up to the ideas of the Christians, who, “if we are not all angels, say we are all devils,”’ have not this freedom of mutual criticism, and the result is an unhealthy communal life full of public purrings of self complacency. If they had to wait before attaining their great object, let them spent the time most profitably in improving their morals. These were the three things on which their movement must be built, the three M’s—Money, Muscle, and Morals.”
Dr. Gaster addressed the meeting setting forth his position. He said this in defense of the IKA:
“Mr. Zangwill had urged that we wanted three M’s—Money, Muscle, and Morals. He; would reverse the order and say that they wanted,
first Morals, then Muscle, and then Money. What had the J. C. A. to do with Zionism? Would Zionism be raised by it at all to a higher pedestal? After all there were but 500,000 Zionists in the world, and what of the other eleven and a half million Jews who were still left. It was their great aim to bring these over to their side; that was surely enough for the moment. At present, could they call themselves the only representatives of the Jewish nation? When, indeed, the whole nation did rise with them, who would attempt to oppose them or to ask them whether they were the representatives of Jewry? Nobody would deny that the J.C.A. had not been a success. But could anyone say that they (the Zionists) had yet been as complete a success as they wished? He was fully intimate with all the work done by the J.C.A. and hard and earnest work it had been. Mr. Zangwill did not know all that has been done. There were others who had labored with as much zeal, and with as much industry, and with as much self-sacrifice for the Jewish people, as they had done themselves. Everybody must be given his due. They would not gain hearts if they heaped up accusations against those who worked independently of them. Zionists represented the old ideals and the old traditions. It was now by active work that they had to proceed. He hoped that they would soon arrive at practical work in Palestine itself. Whatever followed would depend on themselves. He hoped that they would not be waiting for money to be forthcoming from the Hirsch Trustees. What they wanted was to be perfectly independent. He would tell them what Cultur was, for somebody before had said that nobody knew. Well, Cultur meant the Jewish spirit of independence, that spirit of education that had drunk at the fountains of the old tradition, that taught them not to be submerged in the abyss of assimilation and that they possessed the key to the future. Those who worked for this Cultur would succeed. He utterly despaired of those who did not believe in it.”