The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 3 · March 1902
157printed page
scan 25 of 56
March, 1902.]
THE MACCABÆAN.
157

International Deputation last year had been wrongly laid at the J.C.A.'s door. (2) That the J.C.A. was desirous of furthering the best interests of Judaism. (3) That Mr. Zangwill's statements condemnatory of its work were the outcome of ignorance.' Like so many defences, that defence proceeded by attributing to him accusations which he did not make. He had never denied that the Association was desirous of furthering the best interests of our people. What he questioned was the competence of the J.C.A. or its methods to further those interests. He had not accused the J.C.A. of rudeness. For he was not thinking of its discourtesy to the International Deputation, which though consisting of eminent Jews sent out by a mass meeting of eighteen hundred persons in Odessa to implore the J.C.A. to succor the starving Palestinean workers and give the Colonists a voice in their own affairs, was never formally received or afforded a full chance of debate. He wished Dr. Gaster could get the J.C.A. to apologize also for its still harsher refusal to give any hearing at all to the workers themselves, to the delegates from the wretched colony of Petah Tikvah, who travelled all the way from Palestine to Paris only to find the door of hope slammed in their wan faces. It was on the J.C.A.'s own report that he based this blame. For it told them that in the previous year they sent out of Palestine 130 families comprising 305 souls. What kind of families? Beggars? No, workers! Just the very element that was needed in Palestine where there are so many Schnorrers. This was his complaint at the Congress and this was fully admitted. To send out of Palestine the very labor force that is needed to develop it was treason to the interests of the Jewish people. He knew the Association was anti-Zionist Mr. Montefiore had told them that the English members objected to the taking over of the Rothschild colonies on the ground that the J. C. A. would seem to be forwarding the Zionist movement, while even the other members of the Council who were favorable to the taking over were inspired by the noble motive that it would be a blow to Zionism. Every year the J. C. A. issues a report, and its manifold activity is contrasted with the empty shouting and flag-waving of Zionism. The annual document, of which he had the latest issue, was marked by its cheerfulness and its childishness. They read: "The sanitary condition of our Cyprus Colony is fairly satisfactory. Nevertheless, nearly all the colonists have suffered with fever." And fur-

ther: "Each colonist possesses a cart with two wheels." It was like a nursery game. "The mill and the pump have not worked this year." Naughty mill and pump! "Some of the departing colonists sold their animals, and there are now only 6 cows, and these give but little milk." Little Bo Peep has also lost her sheep. Nowhere is it realized that all the cattle in all the colonies in all the continents do not amount to the possessions of one big Australian farmer. The report began with the Argentine, and congratulated itself upon only one colony, Moiseville, and even here there is only one crop, lucerne grass, that is really satisfactory. And these colonists only "hope to arrive at prosperity." The seriousness of the situation lies in the fact that the vast majority of the Argentine colonies, twenty to wit, belong precisely to Entre Rios, and that in Entre Rios there are no crops and no cows. Otherwise all is well. In all these vaunted colonies there are only 906 colonists with their families. The total number of the J.C.A.'s undertakings, managed or subsidized, is no less than 193. The annual meeting in Paris to consider this report was not even attended by the shareholders. The 193 undertakings were polished off in the twinkling of an eye, the Brobdingnagian balance-sheet was passed unquestioned, and — hey presto! the Trustees were back on the boulevards. Suppose instead of doing so much wilful good the Trustees believed a little in the Jewish national spirit. Suppose they had allied their millions with this great force? Theirs is the most colossal example in history of work without faith.

Dr. Gaster defended the Association against charges he did not make; but what of the charges he did make? What blame did he fasten upon them? It was that at a critical period of Jewish history when a Jew had been received by the ruler of Palestine, and had said enough at the Maccabæan Society to open up an extraordinary possibility of fruitfulness for the sterile Hirsch millions, these Trustees did not officially invite Dr. Herzl to a conference. They often heard it said that if Dr. Herzl had something up his sleeve why did he not produce it? But what statesman revealed to the public at large his confidential negotiations? Grand Rabbi M. Zadoc Kahn, another of the Trustees, said last year at a public meeting, "Whenever the idea of a Jewish State is realized, it is the J. C. A. that will furnish it with all the elements necessary for its existence." For its existence? Why not for its birth? In 1900 they had that lamentable immigration of unhappy Roumanians, and the