The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 3 · March 1902
155printed page
scan 23 of 56
March, 1902.]
THE MACCABÆAN.
155

ation known what its actual status was, nor have the individual societies felt sure as to their relationship to the Federation.

The Congress has done a wise thing in officially acknowledging the existence of these Federations, and thus giving them a legal standing.It has also gone further and has provided forthe contingency of more than one Federationbeing found required in one and the same country. This is of especial importance for us in theUnited States: the immense tract of land to becovered makes it impossible to overlook thewhole field from one single center ; and it is quiteprobable that with the growth of the Zionistmovement here we shall in course of time establish other centers. In order to put these newFederations upon a substantial basis, and to prevent their formation except in cases of absolutenecessity, the rule was laid down that any newFederation that is to be formed must consist ofat least fifty societies, with five thousand shekel-paying members. This latter rule, of course, applies only to new Federations which are to beformed, and is not applicable to those which arealready in existence.

While the smaller Actions Committee watches over the formation of the Federations, and must necessarily give its consent before any new one is formed, it does not interfere with the societies either individually or collectively. It has its representatives in the members of the larger Actions Committee, and carries on its correspondence with the societies or Federations through the members of this committee belonging to the different countries. These members are elected by the Congress itself, which therefore practically keeps its control over the whole organization. It will usually be found that the members of the larger Actions Committee are members also of the governing body of the Federation in their particular country. But this need not necessarily be the case, and no provision to this effect is found in the Constitution. The members of the larger Actions Committe are simply the representatives of the smaller committee for their respective countries. It seems to every one that this arrangement is a wise one under the circumstances; for while it gives the Federations the legal standing for which they have been asking for some time, it prevents the smaller Actions Committee becoming mixed up in questions which are local in character and which are beyond the ken of their actual observation or knowledge. It ought to be the wish of the Zionists in every country to have as many Federations as possible, because each

new Federation must represent a large increase both in the number of societies and in the number of actual Zionists. We hope that this will prove to be the case here in the United States.

R. G.

The British Dilemma

OUR British brothers are not in a pleasant frame of mind just now, with Mr. Zangwill attacking the IKA and their own British Brothers attacking them. At least those of our race who are on the road to thorough assimilation, and who consider the IKA the buffer against which the alien must first beat his head before he may enter, do not find it pleasant to realize that after all, certain duties are forced upon them which seem inconsistent with their duties as citizens of the British Empire. They have not the heart to resist the appeals of their persecuted brethren, so urgently and alarmingly made; and yet to answer these appeals without acknowledging the racial connection which they would forget, compels the formulation of a plan which is absolutely futile. They seem to say: "If it should happen that Jews do clamor for admittance, we shall take care that they shall not starve, but further than that we can not go. And we may perhaps take a few of them to some out of the way corner, where they will be out of danger. But nothing more." Has anything been done to solve the question of persecution, has the world problem which the status of the Jew forces upon our attention been in any way touched? Charity and philanthropy do not cover the sins of shortsightedness and enlightened selfishness. Do the English Jews think to combat the Roumanian persecution by opening harbors of safety in England or in Argentine, or by opening soup kitchens? No fund under the sun can provide for the natural wants of masses of people displaced from home and employment; money cannot alleviate their distress. Nothing can be accomplished if the persecution continue and no adequate home be established where the persecuted may be collected.

Now our English brethren find themselves between Scylla and Charybdis. They may not deny their brethren—although a few have taken that course; but that way is cowardice, for the racial sympathies tug at their heartstrings and it is but an assumed indifference; nor can they fail to assert their British patriotism when the plea is