The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 2 · February 1902
59printed page
scan 7 of 80
Facsimile · scan 7 of 80
Scan of p. 59
Text · transcribed from the scan

work as he would have done had he possessed private means. Among the Jews alone the delusion exists that a man can study without having money. Only among us does one think of being able to penetrate into Secondary and High Schools, and of working with the head without filling the stomach and without having to cover one's nakedness; that one can acquire knowledge without having to pay for it with money and time.

We have the mournful privilege of having produced the type of beggar-student; exceptionally he is to be found among other peoples, but as a rule the beggar-student is a specifically Jewish phenomenon. The condition under which the beggar-student pursues his studies are not difficult to guess. The State, Municipal and Corporation Scholarships seldom fall to his share. The number of Jewish communal and private foundations for the support of students is very small, and it is no exaggeration that on the average there are fifty candidates for one Scholarship. During the period of his studies, the beggar-student endeavors to earn something. He rushes with wild eagerness after lessons which pay wretchedly, and which, at the time when his character and mind are at their best, rob him not only of time and strength, but also of his pride and self-respect. He who does not give lessons, bungles at journalism and literature, translates, copies, or occupies himself with still more humble work. Study, which should be his foremost object, sinks into a secondary position. The beggar-student has, therefore, only a few lost moments to spare, and devotes to study instead of a fresh and clear mind, a mind distracted and full of a thousand ordinary cares. The examination, in such conditions, becomes for him a terrible venture into which he enters with a trembling heart. He knows that he is not prepared; he knows that he has no honest qualification, but hopes for a miracle, and if it should happen, his conscience tells him that he has had undeserved good luck.

During his student days he is badly nourished, ill-clad, badly provided with books, without the lightness of mind or the aspiration after distinction which science spreads among its votaries. The more fortunate fellow-students who have no perception of tragedy of his wan cheeks or his threadbare coat, despise the beggar-student. The teachers have a strong antipathy to the students whom they regard as incompetent and dirty, and they acquire a spirit of anti-Semitism from which so liberal a mind as that of Billroth could not

keep itself free. During the term of his studies,the beggar-student is a proletarian ; at his examination he is playing at a game of hazard ; onlywhen he has his diploma in his pocket does hebecome once again a free individual. Thus thedreadful paradox arises among us that the periodof study which among all other peoples opensthe road to a higher social status, does not raise,but wherever possible, lowers us.

The poor Jew who raises himself to one of the learned professions, does not cease to be a proletarian, for he renders proletarian every learned calling into which he enters. He becomes of inferior worth, and family cares press him to depreciate the value of his work. That there is no lack of capacity, earnestness and sense of duty, but a lack of worldly means is proved by the small minority of those Jewish students who belong to the well-to-do middle class, and who during their course of studies are able to work without being obliged to earn a living for themselves or (as is often the case with the poorer class), for their families. These few students, who are favored by fortune, produce some of the highest minds altogether out of proportion to their numbers.

It is often adduced as proof of the thirst of the Jews for culture, that in the Secondary and High Schools they are represented proportionately more numerously than in the population. I am of opinion that, in this respect, we are for once in a way flattered. The Jews do not study to so large an extent for love of study, as on account of despair. The train of thought which leads the poorest Jews to study induces, in its droll absurdity, laughter and tears at the same time. The poor Jew is as little endowed with the means for the noblest of callings as he is for the most pretentious. Why then should he not choose the most pretentious? He lacks nothing that he would not want for the most modest, viz., everything. Many a Jew, who has mythically brought things far, must inwardly confess to himself: "As I could not become a laborer working by the day, there was nothing left for me but to become a Minister."

III.

Such is the economic situation of the Jewish people in its entirety. We are a people "of the air" and culture proletarians. We live on the chapter of accidents and on miracles. We possess no reserve for to-morrow, no capital for to-day. Our day laborers cannot search for the best markets. Our tradesmen hang tremblingly