The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 2 · February 1902
57printed page
scan 5 of 80
Facsimile · scan 5 of 80
Scan of p. 57
Text · transcribed from the scan

yet been done. No one can justly be reproached for this. Even in States which command money, competent statisticians, an energetic and obedient staff of workers, the acquisition of comprehensive statistics is a weary, difficult and costly task. We have not these materials at our disposal. We have to rely only on good-will, on voluntary efforts, and, unfortunately, to a great extent on inexperience. Our unofficial work would cost a great deal more than compulsory official work, and we have incomparably less money than States. We can not reckon on the willingness of Jewish millionaires to make sacrifices for researches concerning the Jewish people. The best among them, in whom Jewish feeling is still the warmest, interest themselves in Jewish history, and in the most favorable cases establish museums of Jewish antiquities and Jewish art; but their interest does not extend to scientific comprehension of the living present of the Jewish people.

Extraordinarily difficult as the task may be of statistically depicting the life of the people in all its material and moral aspects, Zionism will not shirk it. Some preliminary work has been done for us in Germany, and we can gratefully avail ourselves of the official statistics, in so far as they concern the Jews. England, France, North America, Italy, Belgium, Holland, the Scandinavian countries and Switzerland possess very comprehensive statistics, but as they do not differentiate between Jewish citizens and the rest of the population, they are of no use for our purposes. In Austria-Hungary, Roumania, and especially in Russia, such a distinction is made, but there the official statistics are incomplete, and we cannot learn from them everything that we require to know about the circumstances of the Jewish section of the populations. With regard to these countries, the most important for the Jewish people, there are available only a few works of individual and irresponsible authors, which only deal with a fringe of the material, and about which we do not know whether they are sufficiently reliable. On this weighty question, the positive knowledge of our people and of its actual circumstances, we are badly or not at all prepared. We ask for data from the few specialists on research, and receive opinions. We seek demography, and receive literature and art. I suffer heavily from the lack of preparatory labors, for it makes it impossible for me to offer you anything more than purely conjectural impressions which one acquires from daily life, from conversations with people of every class and

from books of every origin, if one is unable to give facts obtained as the result of patient investigation.

II

To sum up these impressions, I must say that the Jewish people, in its entirety, is incomparably the poorest of all the peoples in the world. I make this assertion unconditionally and unreservedly. There is no people in the world that possesses less than we, or even so little as we do. Even the remotest savages are incontestably richer than we are. The Eskimos have the right, the room, and the material to build their snow-huts how and where they will, and to hunt seals where they can. Even the Fire-worshippers can kindle their fire and fish where they choose. The Jewish people alone has not the right to give unrestricted play to its energies, to satisfy its most essential physical needs.

And while, economically, it is worse situated than the poorest savages, it still has all the needs of civilized beings, increased by certain expensive needs of a religious nature that a non-Jew does not know, and so, relatively speaking, it is far poorer than the poorest tribe of savages, below whom it already stands in the scale of absolute property. He who has a humanely feeling heart must shudder when he regards the economical position of the Jewish people in its entirety. Especially in the East, where the great majority of our brethren are settled, is the Jewish people a people of unemployed. In the last generation we have seen desperate efforts to bring about a change, an improvement. We have now numerous Jewish artisans and day-laborers, but the economic type, that in the East still most frequently occurs, is that of the man of air (Luftmensch), that specifically Jewish phenomenon of grown up, fairly healthy men that at night sincerely or superstitiously regard it as a wonder when they happen to have found a morsel of bread for themselves and those dependent on them to struggle through the day.

I must insist on calling "the man of air" a specifically Jewish type. The English city knows the loafer, the idler who slouches at street corners and about public-house doors, and waits for a chance to make an honest or dishonest penny. Naples once knew the Lazzarone, who fished a little, begged a little, stole a little and idled a great deal. But from these doubtful characters that, on the border of the normal tavern life, oscillate between professional mendacity and crime, the Jewish man of air differs in that he is