cry out as loud as he likes that he is not of it.The world will simply laugh at him and “pass to the order of business.” Dr. Landsberg’s final word is that “The Jewish question will be solved sooner or later . . . . . . when justice will prevail everywhere.” Of this we have as little doubt as the reverend gentleman himself has.But, as it will probably be rather later than sooner, we should like to know what he proposes to do in the meanwhile. Dr. Landsberg is very secure in his adopted home in Rochester, New York. He enjoys the confidence of his fellow citizens, and has a large and useful sphere of work. The question whether sooner or later does not touch him in the least, but how about the toiling and struggling masses in the Ghettos of Eastern Europe? The question is unfortunately within the sphere of their most practical politics, and it makes a great deal of difference to them whether the relief that they desire and have the right to ask, comes sooner or later.
We are glad to find so welcome an adherent in the “Jewish Criterion” of Pittsburgh. Both the Rev. Mr. Leonard Levy and Mr. Charles Joseph proclaim themselves Zionists; but, of the “colonization” kind only. If they will take the trouble to look a little more closely into the history of what this benevolent or charitable “colonization” Zionism has done in the past, they will readily see how it has completely broken down. A people cannot be redeemed by benevolence and charity; only by its own efforts can it place itself in a condition where it can work out its salvation upon its own lines. Israel of old had to break away somewhat rudely from the land of oppression, and strenuously to struggle to earn its coveted freedom. A great part of modern Israel will have to do likewise. Benevolence can be doled out to an individual; it is death to a people.
The National Fund
THE Zionist movement, like the rabbi of the story, has blown the breath of life into the nostrils of the moribund Jewish people. The first movement of the Jewish people, after it had gained consciousness, was the establishment of the Jewish Colonial Trust. The Jewish Colonial Trust stands firmly on its feet, it is ready for work, and the Zionist movement now proposes to give it an instrument to wield, a duty to perform. That instrument is the National Fund, created at the last Congress.
The National Fund means no precipitate action.It means foresight; it means preparation. Itstands for practical measures, and its creatorsfully understand the situation.. The land isthere, wisdom has declared that it is worthy ofredemption, the persecuted people are waiting,and the power in control, whose encouraging attitude is unmistakeable, is ready for negotiations.In the interregnum between conventions, theCongress rightly felt that it must create a powerequal to the situation, to take advantage of anyopportunity chance or labor may bring to pass.
There should be no hasty conclusions drawn. The Fund is a potential power. Should it be quiescent for some time, there need be no harsh criticism. It will be brought into active life by the leaders of the movement working upon elements that have shown signs of co-operation.
In the meantime the money the Jewish people will accumulate, kept in scrupulous security, guarded by all legal protection, will be a further test of the solidarity of the movement. If Zionism succeeds in furnishing nothing but provocation to the Jewish people, opportunity to unite, opportunity to show racial consciousness, it will have proved itself a valuable factor in our progress. The National Fund then will be watched to see how Zionism has welded together the ancient people, welded them together in an effort to create a force which shall sweep away the persecutions that daily in European countries become more burdensome, a force strong enough to emancipate the oppressed of our race.
The American Israelite's Beams
THE "American Israelite" of Cincinnati is one of our oldest friends. It has given Zionism a great deal of attention; and whenever it honors us it dips its pen more than ordinarily deep into the inkpot out of which soar its most terrible adjectives and its most ribald nouns. Unfortunately our editorial office is incomplete, — at least in respect to this particular inkpot. We are unable to make all sorts of foolish charges and to call names. We try to think that the writers in the Israelite really mean what they say.
To do this is by far the greatest tax to which our endurance has yet been put. According to the very lucid writer in the columns of our contemporary, "Zionism and Anti-Semitism are twin enemies of the Jews ;" all Zionists are "fools" and have "diseased minds too weak to bear the