The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 2 · February 1902
93printed page
scan 41 of 80

Dr. Herzl's tempered statement as to the status of the Zionist movement to-day.

To those who have followed the course of the IKA since the death of its founder, the statement made by Mr. Zangwill will not come as a surprise, and the attempt of Dr. Gaster, at the recent meeting of the Anglo-Jewish Association, to exculpate the IKA itself on the plea that what has been done or has not been done in connection with the colonies in Palestine, is the work of a single Committee, must certainly fail of its object. According to all methods of parliamentary procedure, a body is held liable for the work done by all its Committees, and if any one Committee has been negligent or has not carried out the intentions of the directors, it is the duty of those directors to change the personnel of the Committee without delay. Thus Dr. Gaster practically gives weight to Mr. Zangwill's complaint and himself refers somewhat bitterly to the more than scant courtesy afforded by that Committee to an important delegation which came to Paris during the last year.

The moneys left by Baron de Hirsch were left, if not in word at least in fact, to the Jewish people, and certainly those whom that money was meant to aid, ought to have some voice in the manner in which it is to be spent. It is fundamentally wrong that a closed corporation, under no obligations to render an account of its work to any one, should have control of such large sums of money. In saying this, we do not for one moment wish to cast the slightest suspicion upon the honorable intentions of the men who have this trust in charge, but this consideration for their private character should not blind us to their public acts.

The Congress has received from the newspaper world at large the attention which its importance deserves. Even such papers within our own ranks whose editors profess not to sympathize with the objects of the whole movement, have properly thought the event of sufficient importance to give it a prominent place in their columns. Of course, discordant notes have not been wanting. Strange to say, these come from out of our own Jewish body, while the Christian press looks on sympathetically at a people trying to help itself in a manner befitting its dignity and its past. To one unacquainted with our Jewish ways and peculiarities this may seem a wee bit curious; but the critical faculty has been so abnormally developed in us Jews, that nothing escapes its sharp edge.

R. G.

Some Critics of Zionism

HERE comes Dr. Tobias Shanfarber in the "Reform Advocate," and reiterates the old time charge that "So many of the followers of the Zionistic movement care so little for Judaism." And the Rev. Dr. Max Landsberg of Rochester, in an interview published in the "Democrat and Chronicle" of that city, tells his interlocutor that "This quixotic scheme found favor among a number of prominent men whose sole connection with Judaism consisted in their descending from Jewish parents, while they had long lost their interest in the Jewish religion." Both these gentlemen must be sadly misinformed upon a fact in regard to which they seem to speak with so much authority. If they could have taken a peep into the synagogue at Basle on the Saturday of the Congress week, they would quickly have changed their view. They would have seen the greater part of the members of the Congress assembled there in public worship. Or, if they will take the trouble to look over the list of officers of the American Federation of Zionists, they will find it to contain the names of quite a number of Jews who stand as firm in their devotion to the religious ideals of Judaism as the two reverend gentlemen themselves do. That some of those high up in our councils have hitherto been connected with their brethren only by racial ties, is true enough; but this will be found equally true in any Jewish movement; not less so in these United States than in any other portion of the globe; not less true in days gone by than in the present.

That the Jewish question, as we understand it, is in the first place an economic one, makes very little difference. We can hold such a view, and at the same time be most fervent advocates of the best religious aspirations of our race. We would go still further and say that the religious situation is so closely bound up with the economic, that the latter must be first bettered in order that the former may be once more placed upon its true and high plane.

In the interview quoted above, Dr. Landsberg says calmly, "To us there is no Jewish race." Such a statement is belied by history and fact. A people that strictly intermarries within its own ranks, that looks upon exogamous connections as opposed to its most vital interests, must needs preserve its racial purity. No matter what ingredients have from time to time been brought in from the outside, that essential purity remains. The individual member of the race may