The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 2 · February 1902
87printed page
scan 35 of 80
February, 1902.]
THE MACCABÆAN.
87

Wise, Mr. Zolotkoff, and Mr. B. Horwitz (Chicago); Canada, Mr. Clarence de Sola; North Africa, Dr. Valentin; South Africa, Mr. L. Kessler ; Switzerland, Dr. Camille Levey ; England, Messrs. L J. Greenberg, J. de Haas, and H. Baker (Glasgow).

The Russian election led to a protest on the part of the Polish element, and one was added as already given, making the number thirteen. Thereupon an attempt was made to the enlarge the German representation, but this did not succeed. For England it was explained that Mr. Zangwill had been nominated by the Permanent Committee, but Mr. Zangwill had intimated through Mr. J. Cowen that he could not serve. A nomination from the hall of Dr. Gaster led to the explanation that the English Zionists adhered to the principle of changing their representatives each year.

At this stage of the proceedings Dr. Kohan-Bernstein resumed his seat on the platform. Another brief scene followed. Dr. Kohan-Bernstein desired to withdraw from the Cultur Commission which had been nominated, and after an interchange of views with Dr. Herzl, the latter energetically stated that he would not allow the proceedings to be disturbed. Dr. Bernstein had threatened that it would again be necessary for him to quit the Congress. He, Dr. Herzl, was prepared to allow matters to come to the point. He had conducted the business in accordance with the wishes of the majority and would not allow the Congress to be threatened.

The vociferous support given this from the body of the hall terminated the incident.

The Executive (Actions) Committee was then nominated. The name of Dr. Herzl was received with a storm of applause, which lasted ten minutes, shout after shout, cheer after cheer, waving of handkerchiefs, throwing of hats, cries of viva, and the singing of Tikvosinah.

It was explained in the further nominations that Dr. Schnirrer could not stand owingto pressure of professional duties.

The Committee elected were :—Dr. Herzl, Dr. O. Kokesch, Dr. Leopold Kahn and Herren Oscar Marmorek and Johan Krementzky.

The next elections were received with cheers. Arbitrators : Dr. Max Nordau, Dr. A Marmorek and M. F. Beer, to sit in Paris.

Congress Counsel: Dr. Max Bodenheimer.

National Fund Commission: Dr. M. Bodenheimer, Dr. S. Rosenbaum, Dr. A. Marmorek, Mr. H. Bentwich, Mr. S. D. Cohen, Professor Gottheil, Dr. Farbstein and Signor Felice Ravenna.

A Cultur Committee were next elected as follows: Messrs. S. Barbosch, M. Dizehoff, and Ben Amir, of Odessa ; Dr. Emil Simonsohn, Dr. Alfred Nossig, and Dr. Heinrich Loewe, of Berlin ; Dr. Gaster and Mr. Israel Zangwill, of London.

The Chairman now offered to resume the Culture and Amelioration debates. Herr Feiwel and Dr. Weitzmann resigned their offices on the Congress Bureau as a protest against the conduct of the Chairman. The first-named ascended the tribune to state this, and was hooted down. Dr. Herzl, whilst appealing for order, pointed out to Herr Feiwel that a similar demonstration had been made against him on quitting the hall. The Cultur debate was resumed at 2.30 a. m. Herr Sokolow, whilst pleading for support for the re-starting of a Hebrew Encyclopædia, protested against the whole Cultur question. An attempt was being made to befog the Congress with misty and indefinite words. What the Cultur Commission had asked for no one objected to, but these things should be asked for on their own ground and in the clearest terms.

The Chairman said it was not an insult to refuse to vote on resolutions without debate. The Congress had not opposed debate, but snatch votes. He repeated what he had said at the end of the first Congress. Zionism would not and should not wrong or injure Judaism. They had avoided the religious question as such, but the Cultur issue had been argued at every Congress. The Congress, itself a Cultural effort, and all the pressure that was being brought to prove that the Actions Committee were against Cultur, was merely agitation. The greatness of the movement was that it not merely united people from different countries, but people of different methods of thought.

Rabbis Reiness and Rabinowicz submitted a series of resolutions:—

(1,) To subvention the National Jewish Library in Jerusalem.

(2.) To organize a statistical Bureau.

(3.) That a Hebrew Encyclopædia was a necessity.

At this moment the "Young Zion" party returned to the sitting, their re-entry being unheeded.

Dr. Herzl, with a few calm words, had these resolutions and the first of the Cultur report passed. The others were rescinded, out-voted or submitted to the Actions Committee for consideration, Dr. Herzl observing that nearly everyone had been under the consideration of the Committee, and mostly had been viewed with favor.