The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 2 · February 1902
86printed page
scan 34 of 80
Facsimile · scan 34 of 80
Scan of p. 86
Text · transcribed from the scan

(7.) That a permanent Commission of “Cultur” be appointed, and its members to meet prior to the next Congress.

(8.) That the Actions Committee provide the Juedische Verlag with the matrix of the Congress protocol for the reprinting and distribution of the addresses on amelioration.

(9.) That the Stockholm Novel Library be requested to add to its collection Hebrew and Jargon nationalistic literature.

Dr. Weitzmann, in supporting the resolutions, protested against Dr. Nordau's description of the Jewish student. Beggar-students are not the rule, and the mass of students studied because of the desire of knowledge and culture. The whole question of culture was now an actual one, as the migration from East to West and West to East compelled them to see the need for raising the understanding of the people.

Rabbi Rabinowicz of Sabotkin, who received an ovation, said it seemed to him that all the trouble raised by the Cultur Question was due to misunderstanding. It was all a question of practice. He had done, he thought, more for Culture in his rayon than anyone else. The Jew who was not a Zionist was still a Jew, though an illogical one. Zionism could not be to Israel what Judaism had been, for Judaism had not passed away. He protested against that view. Zionism should support both the people and their faith. The last word on civilization had been spoken on Mount Sinai, for civilization had not gone beyond that in its ideals. Mr. Zangwill was wrong to regard Jochanan ben Zaccai as the father of anti-Zionism. Mr. Zangwill would have been an anti-Zionist then, as he would have been in the days ofthe Crusades. Zionism was a practical issue. The return was now becoming practical, and that was the merit of the movement and the reason why sinking all other issues, they should rally to the cause.

Rabbi Reiness, in a fairly long speech, said the future should be allowed to take care of itself. Let the masses make for themselves that Culture which should be possible in Palestine under the conditions that would naturally establish themselves.

Herr E. M. Lillien said culture and religion should be friends.

A scene now followed. Dr. Herzl stopped the debate on a proposal to closure the debate. He had been misinformed as to the nature of the discussion, but he would not allow the Congress to be forced by a snatch vote. The election of the Actions Committee was the most important.

question before the Congress, and he would go on with the Agenda and when urgent matters had been disposed of, he would allow the discussion to be resumed. The "Young Zion" protested. They had, they said, a promise that the resolutions should be put. Dr. Herzl said he had held the balance fairly, and he would not permit a snatch vote on an issue so serious that it had occupied the attention of four Congresses.

The “Cultur” element forced the position by their resolution, and the chairman decided that the Congress should decide whether the Agenda or the “Cultur” question should be proceeded with. The question being put, the majority voted, amid many cheers, for the Agenda. Thereupon thirty-seven members of the Congress, including Dr. Kohan-Bernstein, left the Hall amid the hooting of the remainder.

The Chairman's appeal for order and the ignoring of the exodus was responded to, and the election of the permanent committees proceeded with, whilst many of the "Young Zion" continued to witness the proceedings from the gallery.

Dr. A. Marmorek for the Permanent Commission, moved that permanent committees should be made up of small committees in each country, and those resident in one town ; moreover, all the Committees should meet six days prior to the Congress to draw up their joint reports. These proposals were then accepted. There were then elected :—

Share Clubs Commission : Dr. M. Bernstein, Mr. Walter Nathan, Mr. H. Bentwich.

Legitimation Commission : Dr. M. Bernstein, Dr. A. Marmorek, Leo Motzkin, Dr. A. H. Reich, M. Dizengoff, with the following Deputies: Messrs. P. P. Baker, S. Veith Dr. C. Weitzmann, Dr. L. Wilenski and Dr. Lozinski.

Greater Actions Committee : Lower Austria, Dr. S. Frenberger ; Bohemia, Dr. Reischer ; Moravia, Dr. B. Sonderling ; Galicia, Dr. Korkis, Dr. Kornhauser, Dr. D. Malz ; Hungary, Dr. D. Oestreicher ; Germany, Rabbi Dr. Rulf, Dr. Max Bodenheimer ; Roumania, Dr. Carl Lippe, Herr S. Pineles, Dr. Moscowitz ; Bulgaria, Herr Carl Herbst ; Servia, Dr. Alkali ; France, Dr. Alexander Marmorek ; Belgium, M. E. L. Tolkowsky ; Holland, Herr E. A. Kann ; Russia, Herrn. Zempkin, Ussischkin, J. Kohan-Bern-stein, Prof. M. Mandelstamm, Prof. Belkovsky, Rabbi Rabinowicz, Dr. Jelsky, Dr. Jasinowsky, Dr. Bendefsky, Herr I. Goldberg, Dr. Victor Jacobson, Dr. Tschlenow ; America, Prof. R. Gottheil, Rev. S. Schaffer, Rev. Stephen S.