Dr. Max Nordau translated the address immediately after its delivery, and his oratory gave it so much point that it was difficult to decide which was the better, the original or the translation. The whole Congress responded to Mr. Zangwill's criticism of the IKA with an ovation which equalled in heartiness anything that had taken place of a like nature at this Congress. Dr. Herzl pointed out that he believed it was inexpedient to debate Mr. Zangwill's resolution. Words were sometimes not weaker in effect because they were not followed up by resolutions, and he thought this would be the case in this instance.
The suggestion of the Chairman was eventually accepted, and the Congress passed to thenext business, that of the continuation of the debate on the organization scheme.
This debate went on steadily till 2.30 a. m. For a long time the sitting was a debate on points of order, and one point alone was debated for two hours—that of the creation of new or additional Federations in countries where at present only one Federation exists. To this was bound a clause providing that the Federations should be the only medium of correspondence between the Actions Committee and the local societies. The resolution was at length accepted, and was followed by another that new Federations should be established under the authority of members of the Actions Committee. This needed the first suspension of the sitting for a conference of the Russian delegates. After a time a compromise was accepted on the latter point, and the debate continued. Another proposition was made to raise the shekel fifty per cent. everywhere and twenty-five in Russia. This was negatived. One new resolution was adopted making "Die Welt" the party organ and subscription to it compulsory upon every organization, and at length the whole scheme was passed.
At 2 a. m. the debate on the Trust was resumed, but the Congress felt unequal to the task of the debate.
Dr. Farbstein read a report on behalf of the Bank Commission, and in their name moved:—
1. That the Congress is of opinion that the Bank is not a private institution but the instrument of Political Zionism. 2. That the Council be required to arrange for the immediate undertaking of business in Palestine. 3. That the Commission recommends that a branch be established in Russia, for the purpose of the agitation for the further sale of shares. 4. The Committee recommends to the Congress the confirmation of the resolution passed by the Third Con-
gress : That founders' shares be not transferred during the life of the holders
Herr Motzkin suggested the adjournment, conditional, however, that the Council of administration should undertake by the voting power given in the Constitution, that nothing should be done at the general meeting of the shareholders, but that all issues should be left to the decision of the Congress.
Monday's Sitting
The Congress resumed again in the morning. The attendance was as large almost as at the outset. The proceedings were twice interrupted so that the general meeting of the shareholders of the Trust might be held. Up to the moment of the debate the delegates were much divided in opinion as to whether the Trust should start business at all, and if so, what business and where. The Russian delegates were divided, though the proposal to start a branch, if it could be legally done in Russia, came from their side. The debate on these issues lasted till 4 p. m., and every possible side issue relative to the Trust was introduced whilst the main issue was being discussed, and it is therefore impossible to record what was said and suggested in the order of the debate. To summarize the debate is, however, no such difficult task. (1) It was the opinion of the majority that the Trust should remain what it is in name, a Palestinean institution with its capital invested as far as possible in safe and easily realizable securities, so as to be available for the purpose of the movement. This was tempered by the idea (2) that it was absolutely necessary to start a branch in Russia in order to promote further subscriptions and to collect the amount still outstanding on shares. It was further promised that (3) the Trust should start a branch in Palestine either for purely banking purposes, or to promote trade in the country. Against this (4) was the desire to give immediate help to the Colonies, which was negatived, and (5) a proposal to start discount agencies everywhere. The Galician and Roumanian sections made a strong effort to obtain branches in their centres, and, incidentally, some striking information was given as to the growth of the Savings Bank movement in Bohemia and Russia. A section of those who opposed business being done, voted for the Russian branch with a capital of £65,000 because in their view it proves theoretically that the Trust is active, while in practice the Russian Government will not give countenance to the projected branch.
