The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 2 · February 1902
82printed page
scan 30 of 80
Facsimile · scan 30 of 80
Scan of p. 82
Text · transcribed from the scan

of the Actions Committee needed definition. It obtained at present sometimes too much, sometimes too little, power from the various federations. A great difficulty was the monetary question : Where independent organizations sent the Actions Committee money, it was hard, in view of the needs of the movement, to return it. On the other hand, he recognized that such money should go through the different federations. To overcome the natural differences that arise in organizations amongst themselves and with the central bodies, he proposed to establish an independent Board of Arbitration. He thought, too, that fifty organizations should have the right to establish an independent federation. The Actions Committee would then only communicate with federations. In general, he regarded the movement as dependent on. a twofold organization, the general movement based on the shekel payers who elected the delegates who formed the Congress which in turn elected the Actions Committee, and the federations dependent on the funds of the societies which united and created them.

Herr Ussischkin (Russia) read a scheme of organization, which proposed that the Congress should be held every third year, and made the federations dependent for their existence on the actions of the Actions Committee. Dr. Bodenheimer then submitted the official scheme of the Organization Committee, which was listened to with the greatest interest. It covered thirty-nine clauses, of which most were in general but not precise agreement with the proposals of Dr. Herzl. Dr. J. Schlenow made a proposal for the holding of the Congress every second year. Herr Schenkin in the broadest jargon contended against the scheme of Herr Ussischkin, and demanded that the Congress should be more confined to practical issues. At the same time he felt the Congress should be the expression of everything in Jewish life, and the organization scheme should be a living Shulchan Aruch. On the main issue Herr Motzkin advocated the holding of alternative business and demonstration Congresses. Dr. Herzl, in reply, said that he wished the organization to be the consequence of the needs in each country. In the smaller Actions Committees he desired men who had personal experience of the handling of money. He pressed that members should have been members of the movement for some years. This would not favor the establishment of a clique for the opposition to the governing party of shekel-pay-

ers who had paid for five years, which was equal to the formation of an alternative government.

to the formation of an alternative government. Mr. David Trietsch wished to alter the program limiting the objects of the movement to acts merely for the poor and those in need. After this the Congress went into Committee on the Scheme, and clause by clause was debated.

At one o'clock a proposal was made to adjourn the debate, but it was out-voted by a large majority. At two o'clock in the morning a count of the House was taken, and 180 delegates were present. Dr. Herzl led the house on every phrase and line of the clauses. The Congress sat till after three a.m., till the last moment, full of animation and supported by an audience which only at the last moment thinned down to fifty persons.

Sunday Morning

The effects of the late sitting were only partially apparent when the Congress re-assembled in the small hall at ten o'clock, and various committees had been sitting for some time, including a conference of medical members of the Congress on the physical condition of the Jews. Dr. Tschlenow took the chair; the gallery was full. The delegates numbered 180. The debate centered round the organization of the Jewish National Fund, and was somewhat exciting as the Actions Committee endeavored to force the passage of the scheme en bloc. The Congress sat at 1.30, when the sitting was suspended for a quarter of an hour, and till that moment no decision had been arrived at on the scheme. On resuming, the differences were modified, though it was not too apparent what the effective difference would have been between the proposal of the Actions Committee and that of Dr. Bodenheimer who, though desiring to imprint the Actions Committee's scheme with the word "provisional," pressed mostly for the creation of a Trustee for the fund. A small element were dead against the scheme, but the situation was ended by a motion testing the opinion of the Congress on the main scheme. From then on to six p. m., Dr. Nordau presided over the resumed organization debate, but it was with difficulty that "a house" was kept.

Dr. Schalit reported on the draft prepared by the Actions Committee at Vienna, of the scheme for the establishment of a National Fund. The idea of founding a Jewish National Fund was mooted at the first Basle Congress by the late Professor Schapira. At the fourth Congress the creation of such a Fund was agreed upon, and it