The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 2 · February 1902
79printed page
scan 27 of 80
February, 1902.]
THE MACCABÆAN.
70

tion and Trust issue. Amid some excitement,Herr Ussischkin submitted the advance of theorganization debate and the postponement of Dr.Nordau's paper. The division of the amelioration papers was submitted. Against this HerrBuber (Vienna) contended, holding that the addresses were united by a common issue. Dr.Herzl maintained that Dr. Nordau's addressshould be given on Friday, but a nightittingshould be held and the Trust discussed thereat.Herr Buber accepted this, and the proposal wascarried by a large majority. The sitting closedwith the reporting of over 900 telegrams of greeting, which Dr. Nordau, who was in the Chair,said was an excellent lesson in the geographicaldistribution of the Zionist forces.

The afternoon sitting began shortly after four,the general attitude being satisfaction with theaddress of Dr. Herzl but dissatisfaction with thereport of the Executive. Dr. Kohan-Bernsteinreported on the Russian section of the movement.The societies had increased from 820 to 965 during the year. The movement had spread andcentres had been established in Central Asia andSiberia. In many towns produce and food co-operative societies had been started. Dr. Golder Paul reported on the Bohemian section of themovement. Herr Schlaposnikoff (Charkow)spoke critically of the Russian report. Dr. Klee(Berlin) reported that the German Zionists hadgrown in numbers, but the Congress must bepatient, for Germany was the country in whichthe protest against the movement had been firstissued. The points was taken up from variousparts of the hall, the speaker being misunderstood. Dr. Avinowitzky, speaking in Jargon,said that they were not satisfied with Dr. Kleebecause he was satisfied. They could not be satisfied because it meant resting on their oars;they criticised because they were themselves dissatisfied, dissatisfied with themselves and wouldremain so until Palestine was theirs. Dr. Jeremiasand others debated against and for Dr. Klee’sversion of the German movement.

Herr Pineles reported on the Roumanian movement favorably, but was contradicted by Dr. Muscowitz, who demanded the creation of a new central organization in Roumania.

Herr Herbst stated that in Bulgaria there were two thousand male Zionists in a total Jewish population of thirty thousand. Herr Abrahmsohn complained on behalf of Hungary that insufficient work had be done by the Actions Committee for

the Zionists in that country. Mr. J. de Hass reported on England. Mons. Antokolsky reportedbriefly on the growth of the movement in France,and Dr. Marmorek greeted the Congress in thename of the Algerian Zionists, whose numberswere increassing in spite of serious difficulties.A considerable Russo-German debate followed,partly criticising the Actions Committee's report, partly expressive of dissatisfaction withlocal efforts. Dr. Pasmanik, of Geneva, whilstreporting favorably on the growth of the movement in Switzerland, claimed that it owed nothingto the students except to those of Berne. He condemned all factions unsparingly. Herr Lewin-sohn, in criticising the debate amidst applauseand dissent, said Dr. Herzl had once declaredZionism was the return to Judaism. It wasnow necessary that the Congress should return to Zionism and abandon outside issues.Other critics were Dr. Rappaport (Galicia),Carp (Braila), Berger, Bychowsky, and Dr.Weissmann.

Dr. Herzl replied for the Actions Committee, sarcastically observing that the reciprocity of condemnations having apparently been made a principle of the Congress, he could, on behalf of the Actions Committee, say they were unthankful for having been so mildly attacked. The report of the Actions Committee could only be equal to the combined activity of the local organizations, and the result of the debate was the self-criticisms of the organizations and the ignoring of the report itself. As to the issues that had been raised, the differences in Roumania had been ended, support had been given to the Jaffa School at the direct instance of the Congress. The Committee declined to employ artificial methods to propagate Zionism in Hungary. It must grow there, as everywhere else, the result of spontaneous feeling. The objection that the report contained light and no shadow was pointless. It could not be expected that the Committee would be its own opposition. As to the Trust, the Actions Committee had no right of interference in the business management. It guarded the money and the policy of the Trust. The proposal made by Wortsman to pay the members of the Actions Committee had been repeated ; no doubt the time would come when the Actions Committee would accept payment, but he would then not be a member of it. If they had money let them give it, as much as they had, not for salaries, but for the direct purposes of the movement. With money they could sow and reap another harvest.