or perhaps were moved by mere impetuosity. The Congress resisted, and as you will have read thirty-seven men, Kohan-Bernstein at their head, left the hall and filed into the gallery to watch the proceedings. The break was temporary though not without its minor scenes, storm signs, possibly the result of the weariness of the flesh during the long hours of sitting.
Is this incident worth more than the record? I am told that I have exulted in the failure of Young Zion at this Congress. I would not be so misconstrued. Inside Congress I am phlegm itself, a parliamentarian with an English culture. Things appeal to me in their sobriety of manifestation; as a democrat above all I respect the decision of the majority. The Young Zion is the hope of the movement in Europe, it adds to the parliamentary character of the Congress, I have no fear of faction, "caves" do not appal me, but—and it is a long but that I recommend to the consideration of every free land born Zionist, we must have solidity of thought and responsibility of attitude. The charm of youth is great, but youth as youth may limn the canvass, it may not bring its fits and starts into the sober proceedings of men wrestling with life and death problems. I believe I have written somewhere of the "Mesopotamias" of the Young Zion, I think yet and I thought so last night as those white faces leant over the gallery, that the worn
out Western crazes may once be introduced into the arena by our half Eastern youth, but once only; that is the "fling of youth," beyond which the "wild oats" of Zionism must be sown for all time, for we live too previously to waste ourselves in such excesses. The cultur problem is not dead, and it should not die, but the first cultur we stand in need of is the parliamentary responsibility of the individual delegate.
Well, we got over the exuberance of youth to the election of the greater Actions Committee and the smaller one with an ovation for Dr. Herzl. We resumed the cultur issue shorn of its excesses and took the cue of the Rabbis and compromised on what in detail we had no very decided opinion. And so we approached the end. The scene lasted just ninety minutes from the moment it was proposed that the next Congress should be held in Hamburg. With the solemn thanks, the self-abnegation and the apology of Dr. Herzl to the last cheer, it was a scene only equalled but in another mode by the end of the first Congress, and this happened at 4 a. m., after nineteen hours of labor. I listened to the last cheer, and the last song—the echoes go out over the hills, over the ocean, to you all in greeting; the last word of the fifth Congress was: Tikvosinah.
J. DE HAAS.
The Proceedings of the Congress
First Day
THE great hall of the Stadt Casino is full of narrow tables, the tribune is green-baize-covered, but there is a slight change. A barrier is drawn round the seats and room is found for two hundred extra visitors. The only drapery in the hall is the banner of the Glasgow Zionist Societies which drapes the tribunal. The gallery is crowded with Basle and Muelhausen folk, besides a fresh crowd of Russian students. In all they count 278 delegates who take their places. The English speaking delegates present are Sir Francis Montefiore, Rabbi Ravinsohn, Liverpool; Dr. Max Bernstein, Messrs. P. P. Baker, J. Cowen, E. Freudenheim, L. J. Greenberg, J. Goldbloom, H. Ginsberg, J. de Haas, M. Kelsen, J. H. Loewe, H. Lozinsky, Suwalski, S. Sarna, M. Shire, B. Shatz, A.
Vecht, D. Wolffe, I. Zangwill, Miss B. Krakowsky ; South Africa, Mr. S. Kessler and the Rev. D. Wasserzug; Canada, Mr. D. Levi; America, Rev. Dr. Shaffer and Mr. B. Horwitz.
The Congress starts its session after ten and Dr. Herzl began to read his address rather before anyone was well aware that the Congress had commenced. [See Dr. Herzl’s address elsewhere.] Dr. Alexander Marmorek, Chairman of the Permanent Commission, reported on the Commissions of the Bureau.
The nomination of Dr. Herzl as President, of Dr. Max Nordau, Dr. E. W. Tschlenow, and Dr. M. Gaster, was accepted with acclamation. Similar greetings were accorded to the Beisitzender (Sub- Vice-Presidents) appointed : Sir Francis Montefiore, Mr. Jacob Moser, (Bradford), Dr. Kohan-Bernstein, Herr Ussischkin, Dr. Alexander Marmorek, Herren D.
