The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 2 · February 1902
70printed page
scan 18 of 80

advantage the high purpose which is served by his separateness, the merging would probably never be complete, while in the process he would encounter a resistance and an agitation against him incomparably severer than any he now has to face; for he would then be influencing social England, while to-day it but influences him.

Such briefly and substantially is the alien immigration question in essence. But when we come to examine its extent we cannot fail to be struck with the utter disproportion existing between its size and the outcry against it. The wildest statements are continually being made as to an alien invasion of England, and as to the character of the “invaders.” Only recently a writer upon the subject asserted that some 60,000 Russian and Polish Jews were dumped down in the East End of London every year! Seeing that the merest acquaintance with the figures published by the British Government from time to time of the number of immigrants arriving, would show this to be a monstrous statement, one is not quite certain whether it were fairer to condemn the wickedness of such a statement, or to pity the abyssmal ignorance it manifests.Another writer recently—sufficient shame was left to him to hide his identity—spoke of the alien Jews who come to England as “the vilest refuse of the world,” “loathsome wretches who come grunting and itching to our shores.” Both these views on the Alien Immigration question I have taken, not from some obscure and irresponsible print, but from a London journal, the Pall Mall Gazette. Why that journal should sully its pages with such unseemly twaddle it is difficult to understand. That those who have the conduct of it believe such nonsense is not for a moment conceivable. I can only conclude that the principles of “Mr. Pamphlet” have entered the Pall Mall Gazette office. “Time has been,” says “Mr. Pamphlet” in the old novel, “The Upholsterer,” “Time has been when I could turn a penny by an earthquake, or live upon a jail distemper, or dine upon a bloody murder; but now that’s all over—nothing will do now but roasting a minister or telling the people they are ruined. The people of England are never so happy as when you tell them they are ruined!” Unhappily, one or two journals with inferior reputations have taken the bad example set them by the Pall Mall, but withal that journal has well held its unenviable place as chief misrepre-senter of the Alien Immigration problem in England.

I will not worry you by retailing to you the

complaints that are made against our people in the East End of London. When men are bent upon vilifying they are neither rational nor reasonable. Fortunately for the truth, in this state of mind people also become contradictory. Thus the Jew in the East End is cursed for being a pauper and is not blessed because he is able to compete with natives to the latter's detriment in trades in which he engages. He is pictured as a monster with all the vices, and grumbled at because " he doesn't even get drunk like other fellows." He is paraded as miserably frugal, and taunted with being ostentatious. But, why run through the gamut? It is the old old story: " When the pitcher falls upon the stone, woe to the pitcher; when the stone falls upon the pitcher, woe unto the pitcher : whatever befalls, woe unto the pitcher."

I have shown that the immigration of Jews to England has been small, I have said that the total Jewish population is in comparison a mere handful. But, paradoxical as it may appear, these facts render the Jewish problem that confronts Jews in England all the greater, all the more grave. For, if you have but this comparatively puny immigration, if you have but this tiny population, at most well under 200,000 all told, if, besides, you have the unique conditions that obtain in England, of absolute freedom and an absence of anything like religious prejudice, nay, if you have, as there exists in England amongst large bodies of the people, a deep regard and admiration for Jews, and a sympathy with their best ideas—if you have all this, and yet despite all, you have this outcry, this venomous aspersion of Jews, how vastly serious is the outlook. For, in England at least with its magnificent freedom, there ought to be no Jewish question. That one is arising there, has arisen, may well make the least observant ponder. Few of us believed, even a score of years back, that a Jewish question could arise in England. Alas! we have sprinkled the lintels and the two sideposts of English Jewry with blood, shed in the nation’s cause, and yet the plague is upon us. Nor do I believe we have as yet felt aught but its first monitions.

I recollect in the poem of the greatest of Italian poets we are told of his vision by the Stygian lake, of his observing the constant commotion upon the surface of the pool, and h:s instructor telling him the cause of it:

This, too, for certain know, that underneath The water dwells a multitude, whose sighs