The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 2 · February 1902
67printed page
scan 15 of 80
February, 1902.]
THE MACCABÆAN
67

start Zionism on. We may be bad men of busi-ne-s, but at least we can say, that despite all our expenses, there is at this moment in the Bank twenty shilling in the pound for every fully paid-up share And there is another thing we can say. We shall never have any death duty to pay, for our money belongs to no man, but to Zionism, and Zionism can never die.

But we are told Zionism is a dream. How can it be otherwise if the Jews sleep? Let them awake, and it will be no longer only a dream. Zionism has a clear purpose, the Hirsch millions have none. As I have said of Palestine, Give the country without a people to the people without a country, so I say of Baron Hirsch's bequest, Give the millions without a purpose to the purpose without the millions.

These millions were left for the salvation of the Jewish people and the directors cannot stand haughtly over their treasure leaving Israel to sweat and agonize. We hear on all sides pity for the poor blind dupes, the Russians and Roumanians, who form their poverty club together, families upon families, week after week, to purchase a one-pound share in our Trust. It is not pitiful; it is sublime. It is the blindness of the Hirsch trustees which is pitiful. But, you will say, they cannot set aside the testator's will. But in England, in my practical country, charitable bequests are frequently transformed, and transformed to wiser purposes when they have become antiquated, and the Zionist idea has moved so fast that already the Hirsch policy is antiquated. It is only fit for M. Reinach's Museums, for Baron Hirsch thought that in the Argentine the Jew could find a settled and lasting home. What are the facts? In the Argentine there are Zionist societies, in the Argentine there is a Dr. Herzl League!

But was Baron Hirsch against Palestine? Would he have barred Zionism from his beneficence? No. This big man prepared for all contingencies. I have obtained the articles of the Jewish Colonization Association. I will read its essential provisions.

The objects for which the Company is established are (1) To assist and promote the emigration of Jews from any part of Europe and Asia, and principally from countries in which they may for the time being be subjected to any special taxes or political or other disabilities, to any other parts of the world, and to form and establish colonies in various parts of North and South America and other countries, for agricultural, commercial and other purposes. (2) To purchase or acquire by donation or otherwise from any Governments, States, etc., any territories, land, or other property in any part of the world, and all concessions, powers and privileges

which may be necessary or convenient for developing the resources of the same and rendering the same available for the purpose of colonization. (3) To accept donations, etc. (4) To establish commercial, agricultural and other settlements in any territories or lands so acquired, except Europe . . . . and to develop same by clearing, draining, fencing, planting, or otherwise. (5 and 6) To construct embankments, roads, railways, bridges, harbors, reservoirs. wharves, fortifications, telegraphs, telephones, mills, factories, synagogues, etc. (7) To obtain any Acts of Parliament, decrees, charters. . . .

Well, gentlemen, I say that such being the provisions of the Trust, it was the duty of the trustees, when they saw the impression Dr. Herzl's movement was making on rulers and governments, to have invited Dr. Herzl to a conference. I do not say that they should have necessarily applied the funds to Zionism, but that they should not have given Zionism a hearing in a public scandal. [Dr. Herzl again interrupted Mr. Zangwill objecting to the use of the phrase, public scandal. After a parley of words, Mr. Zangwill continued, modifying the expression]. Then I will say that will be a blot on their name when the scroll of our history is written. They were not merely bad business men, they were poor stewards. If Baron Hirsch had been alive he would have taken steps to meet Dr. Herzl, and if these two big men had met, I have no fear of the result. But the trustees! Do you know what they replied to the Jews who, being thrown out of work in Palestine by the sudden transference to the J. C. A. of the Rothschild Colonies, said to them: 'Give us 400 francs and we will gain our own livelihood upon this soil.' They replied: 'No, but here are 1,000 francs if you will go to the Argentine.' Gentlemen, can we wonder they published no balance sheet? And we, whose balance sheet is open to the world, are the dubious business men.

We are the despised, and they are surrounded by incense. But what says the Psalmist of idols? “Eyes have they but they see not, ears have they but they hear not, they have feet but they walk not.” But even the Hirsch Trustees are not yet verloren. Their eyes may yet be opened. They must see that you cannot roll a stone up a mountain. How much easier it is to teach children who wish to learn than those who must be coaxed with sugar; how much easier to plant the willing in Palestine than to bribe the unwilling to Argentine. So that I say to the Trustees, if you are practical business men give to Zionism, and I remind them bis dat qui cito dat, and if they do not give soon the day may come