The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 2 · February 1902
66printed page
scan 14 of 80

to dwindle into a hole and corner affair? It is to help drag it back from its darkness that I am going to move a resolution to-night.

The new Moses, looking around on his people in their bondage, could see no salvation but in a new Exodus. Whither? To a new world, he thought, and so he directed an emigration mainly to the Argentine. With what result? It has been said that the truest philanthropy is to make two blades of grass grow where before grew only one. Of Baron Hirsch's philanthropy it may be said, that he made two schnorrers grow where before grew only one. Colonel Goldsmid, the Director, has told us how there were sent out to him for colonists old men without children, the sickly, the sweepings of the slums of great cities.

What does this failure prove? Only that the conception was bad, and the execution worse. All pioneers must dig in the dark. But Baron Hirsch was a big man and big men learn from their own mistakes. It is only little men and creatures low in the scale of organization who never change. Had Baron Hirsch lived to see the modern Zionist movement, had he beheld an eager young generation, anxious to work out its own destiny, with its own muscles, on its own soil, he would have rejoiced at the opportunity of spending his money fruitfully instead of uselessly.

But the big man died, and the trustees reigned in his stead. Over two hundred million francs, supplemented later by perhaps another hundred millions from the Rothschild Colonies, passed into the hands of a mixed company of Parisians and Londoners, without plans, without unity, without fixed aims, some desiring the disappearance of Jews, others merely the disappearance of Judiasm, all agreeing only in hating the idea of all Jewish concentration. Little-Israelites one might call them, though you may be quite sure that the English members are anything but Little Englanders, and that the Parisians are ardent Chauvinists.

Our Company is reproached for not being managed by men who are famous business men. Well, if the famous business men are all busy making their fortunes, they cannot turn aside to make the fortune of their people. We must take what we can get—and we are very well satisfied. The best business men are not those who have made fortunes for themselves, and the Chancellor of the Exchequer is not usually the richest man in the Kingdom. However, take it that we have bad business men, and that our few million

francs are in danger. But what of the directors of these 300,000,000 francs? How is it nobody trembles over these men and these millions? Who are these men? Certainly there is one famous financier amongst them. But how can he possibly find time? I suspect that he is but a golden figure head. The one I know best—Mr. Claude Montefiore [the report of the session at which this address was delivered credits Dr. Herzl, the presiding officer, with interposing remarks to the effect that no names be mentioned] is a man of fortune, lofty character and scholarship, a man who has never earned a penny in his life but has nobly lost many a penny in running a Jewish Review. This Oxford dreamer, what is he doing in this galley? Then there is a Frenchman, another scholar who is attached to museums and who scarcely can be expected to deal with living things. Then there is another Frenchman, of whom I only know that he is President of the Alliance Israélite.

Well, I will venture to offer him a respectful suggestion. Let him read the Jewish papers of forty years ago. There he will find a bitter cry of alarm at the foundation of a new and mischievous organization, full of menace to the position the Jews had acquired in Europe, sowing the seeds of Judenhetze. He will find terrified correspondents and frightened fathers of families denouncing the new organization, political in character, and therefore dangerous and un-Jewish. That new organization so dangerous, so un-Jewish, was the Alliance Israélite, now rightly recognized as one of the pillars of Israel's glory.

I appeal to the President of the Alliance, I appeal to the fellow-trustees, to skip those forty years in our case, to profit by the lesson of history, and come at once to an understanding of Zionism, to an appreciation of our movement. We want (and now I must use names) Mr. Claude Montefiore with us before he becomes a centenarian, and I fully hope that both he and Sir Francis will emulate their illustrious relative and be centenarian Zionists. For, if these trustees do not come over and join us, I see no purpose for their millions to subserve, nothing but a series of extravagant experiments. Baron Hirsch was not a verlorener Jude, but I very much fear his money will be verloren. You know how bad a beginning has been made, how through lack of foresight some 25,000,000 of francs had to be paid to the British Government as death duty. Add the millions paid to the lawyers to fight the case, and you already get enough to