The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 2 · February 1902
62printed page
scan 11 of 80

If the causes of the evil are recognized, it will not be impossible to minimize them to a certain extent. The Jew engages in fruitless occupations. He opens shops without goods in places where there are no customers, but only other tradespeople and empty shops. He wishes to be an agent where there is no movement in trade, and therefore nothing to negotiate. These Jewish tradesmen and agents must be attracted to handicrafts. “This is unpractical! it is impossible!” Well: Every day hundreds of Talmudists, impoverished shopkeepers and loafers, who have never worked with their ten fingers, emigrate to London or New York, where in a few weeks, nay in a few days, they learn tailoring or shoe-making. What they learn in New York or London they can learn equally well in Lodz and Bialystok. And the capable shoemaker and tailor stands economically far higher than the tradesman without goods and customers.

"But there are already too many Jewish workingmen in the East, and they are dying of hunger." True. But for a specific reason; because there is no need for so many working men in one place and because the few who can earn somewhat of a living endeavor to ruin each other through a suicidal competition. This can be prevented if they will unite instead of fighting each other. They must give up labor anarchy and organize themselves. Not competition but co-operation; this is our urgent advice. Our brethren in the East do not enjoy freedom of locomotion. They must remain where they are. This renders it necessary that everywhere all the workmen should combine into an exclusive manufacturing association, and for handicrafts, the produce of which cannot be exported, to employ only those workpeople for whom there is need and the means of existence on the spot.

Without funds, such co-operative associations cannot be established. But the little money that is required and suffices for this object is available, and yet it is recklessly thrown out of the window. A hundred thousand Jews annually emigrate from the East to the West. Under whatever conditions they are sent away, the journey costs money. The emigrants spend millions every year in travelling. What benefits do these millions confer? None. It may perhaps be said that they are the price which the fugitives from the Ghetto pay for freedom. Oh, this freedom ! In the sweating dens of East London and New York, the Jewish day-worker has no more freedom than in Russia, Galicia and Roumania. Let him remain where he is. He can

there learn the trade which he wants to learn in London. He can there make the clothes and boots which he makes in London. And he could send his goods to the markets of the world instead of travelling himself. If he earns the money at home which he makes by working in London, he is almost in good circumstances. What is a starvation wage in London is a living wage in Minsk or Wilna, Jassy or Galatz. And the workman is not torn from his family, his circle, and his habits. The travelling expenses which he would save, and which he has or can obtain, would be ample to lay the foundations for co-operative associations that can carry on business with a small capital. Cloth, leather, and all other articles required for the manufacture of clothes and boots, the manufacturers would willingly supply on three or six months' credit. The manufactured goods would at once be saleable, and the workman would immediately receive his wages in whole or in part.

For this purpose nothing is necessary but the industrial and commercial organization of co-operation. On the spot public spirit and discipline are necessary; in the market, competent commercial representatives. Then the machinery will work smoothly, and starving loafers will be converted into producers, who will live in a creditable manner and be able to save a little.

Organization! this is the first and last word on the economic subject. And what is more competent to organize the helpless chaotic Jewish mass than Zionism. Let it take in hand the formation of co-operative societies. By this means it will give bread to the hungry, lead those who have been neglected into the paths of discipline, and convert weeping and helpless beggings into energetic and reliable future citizens of Zion.

When once the tailors and shoemakers have become competent, then we can think of introducing higher-class handicrafts. Then money will be forthcoming to open technical schools and workshops, and to pay capable teachers. And so we will succeed in bringing improved material conditions, and certainly respect and self confidence into places where misery now prevails, and we will form a people who, when the hour strikes, will tread the soil of their ancestors with a firm step, assured of being able everywhere to earn their living honorably and well.

VII.

I will not enter into the question of spiritual elevation. Everything that can be said on this subject is but empty phrases, so long as the