objection to the introduction in the executive of an element which has never shown any organizing skill has never been able to formulate a policy and has adopted the unusual motto, for Zionists, that “only foreign Jews can be true Zionists.”
Unless a wiser policy is adopted by the presentleaders of the English Eederation, the Zionistorganisation in the British Empire, of whichZionists have been proud, will become a thing ofno value. Certainly it is short sighted policy forany one class to arrogate to itself the sole rightto guide the Zionist affairs. Zionist organizationhas tended to national federation and from national federation to international union. Thepresent movement has encouraged such a methodof organization. A federation presents a trulydemocratic organization, mobile enough to present a solid front to opposition when the caserequires it. Therefore, all disintegrating influences which tend to undermine international,union and, hence, national federation, should becondemned. We hope that our Fnglish brethrenwill see their folly in this respect.
The Seminary and Prof. Schechter
THE cause of Jewish Culture is to be congratulated when Prof. Schechter opens his first session in the Seminary. But there must be no hesitancy on the part of the Jewish public to respond to his efforts.
Neither Prof. Schechter nor Dr. Cyrus Adlerwho is to be the administrator of the "businessend" while Prof. Schechter directs the Educational end, would lend himself to any movementto divert the Seminary from the intention of itsfounders, namely, to perpetuate Orthodox Judaism, intelligent, historical Orthodox Judaism,which insists upon fidelity to the past, sincereadherence to religious duty and the ideal in human conduct.
Nor would any of the donors to the Endowment Fund countenance, much less attempt, any “surrender of the ideals of the founders. The donors are not men to bribe; they are sensible men who recognize that Jewish Culture rests upon Jewish Learning, and that without Jewish Culture or Jewish Learning, Judaism must become an invertebrate mummy, which all the fine clothes of Reform Judaism and all the ceremonials of miscalled Orthodox Judaism cannot gal- vanize into life.
Shall we attempt a solution of the mystery which to some enshrouds the movement?
Perhaps it is this .
Perhaps it is this . Reform Judaism for many, too many, has come to mean mere words.
come to mean mere words.Orthodox Judaism for many, too many, hascome to mean mere ceremonies.
The real Judaism should be real lives, conduct.And this real Judaism, leal Judaism, true-heart-ed, loyal, faithful, is the Judaism which Prof.Schechter is to inculcate, and for the perpetuationof which the donors establish the Fund.
Were it otherwise, Prof. Schechter could not, would not come.
Were it otherwise, the help of honorable men could not, would not be offered.
Were it otherwise, the Endowment Fund could not, would not be accepted.
May what is called Reform Judaism to-day, and what to-day is termed Orthodox Judaism, both be benefited by the influence of Jewish Culture, Jewish Learning, as the foundation of Jewish lives and Jewish homes — as the inspiration for Jewish conduct.
H. PEREIRA-MENDES.
The State and the Sabbath
THE present Sabbath law agitation presents to us, as citizens of a democracy, the proposition : Shall the State or municipality establish a legal day of rest, or if not establish, seal with legality the common day of rest. As citizens of a democracy, our reply must be, whether Jews or Christians: Let the State keep its hands off.
If it were possible to consider the Sabbath from the industrial or the hygienic points of view only; if it were possible to eliminate the idea of a rest day as a religious obligation from the idea of a rest day as a physical and mental duty, resting in civic obligation,—then a statute establishing or recognizing Sunday as the Sabbath day of the nation should be enacted.
But that elimination is impossible. With all classes, except those who are atheists or agnostics, the Sabbath day is a recognized religious tenet. It is a vital part of the Jewish religion, and to the Christian, more so than to the Jew, who has had his religious services week-days as well as Saturdays, the day has become the day of all days for religious worship.
A fierce struggle sundered the Church and the State. Battles were fought for religious liberty, un-