The Maccabaean · Vol. II, No. 1 · January 1902
22printed page
scan 22 of 52
Facsimile · scan 22 of 52
Scan of p. 22
Text · transcribed from the scan

ther knowledge nor character enough to answer unjust attacks from without the camp of Jewry and to face the inevitable misunderstanding which meets pretty much all that Jews do or say. Jews who tremble at the advances which the Zionist movement is making, and, unable to justify their standing aloof from it, are obliged to resort to any expedient in endeavoring to argue themselves into a tenable position.

We do not, of course, class the editor of "The American Israelite" with these. He has knowledge and character, and much worldly wisdom besides, but his arguments are not convincing, although we have no doubt that many of his readers think that he writes "just grand."

Some of the worthiest opponents of Zionism are contributors to the columns of "The American Israelite." We rather admire, and certainly respect, their opposition, because it is founded upon sincere convictions and is fortified with a measurable show of reason and argument. But the editor really must pardon us if we fail to take him seriously. We do not ask him to discontinue his valuable editorials on Zionism. The movement is great, world-wide, and profoundly serious, and a little unconscious humor like that of our esteemed editorial brother is appreciated.

DAVID WERNER AMRAM.

"Comfort ye, My People"

IN a very earnest review of George Eliot’s Daniel Deronda, published some years ago in “Macmillan’s Magazine” and reprinted in a volume entitled “Jewish Ideals,” Mr. Joseph Jacobs discusses the character of “Mordecai” and in the course of that discussion said the following, which is well worth reproducing :

"Even if one disagrees with Mordecai's views,one may at any rate pay him the respect due toan energetic leader of opposition and recognizein him the leader of those who refuse to believethat Israel's part in history is played out, andthat her future policy should be to amalgamatewith the nations as soon as possible, letting herglorious past sink into an antiquarian study, instead of living as a perennial spring of politicalaction . . . . . . . . But the new birth of Judaism and its revelation to the world are, in Mordecai's opinion, indissolubly connected with thenew birth of the Jewish race as a nation . . . . .And here again history confirms his views. Forthe life of Judaism has been connected with thehistory of Jews in a way such as has been thefate of no other religion. The very name of itsbelievers displays this intimate connection; ofall religions Judaism alone has been named afterthe race of its believers . . . . . . . . Still, the religious trust that has kept the national life

throbbing through the centuries has been the conviction that the Messiah who shall spread Judaism to the four corners of the world will be a Jew by race as well as in creed And Mordecai's views of the resumption of the soil of the Holy Land by the holy people are the only logical position of a Jew who desires that the long travail of ages shall not end in the total disappearance of the race . . . . Unless some such project as Mordecai has in view be carr'ed out in the next three generations, it is much to be feared that both the national life of Jews and the religious life of Judaism will perish utterly from the face of the earth. 'A consummation devoutly to be wished ' the scoffers may say; but not, surely, those in whose veins runs the blood of Israelites, and who have the proud heritage of God's truth to hand down to their children "

The English Zionist Federation

WE learn with regret of serious dissension in English Zionist circles which threaten to destroy the national organization. Mr. J. I. Loewy, a prominent Manchester Zionist and a member of the first executive of the English Zionist Federation, has severed his connection with that body. In justification of his resignation, Mr. Loewy charges the Zionists of East London with having captured the organization so that it is now nothing but an East End committee. There is a vast difference between a local federation headed by ambitious leaders and a national organization embracing Great Britain and Ireland. The charge made by Mr. Loewy is a serious one and, if true, is symptomatic of impending collapse of the English organization. In fact, since the retirement of Dr. Moses Gaster, Mr. Joseph Cown and Mr. L. J. Greenberg from the organization, Zionism in England, so far as organized effort goes, has not progressed as it should. When the above mentioned men led, new societies were organized, meetings were held everywhere, and the movement was truly alive. But gradually the leaders withdrew for one cause of another. Now Mr. Loewy resigns, and his criticism or justification is practically that of all who have hitherto helped in organizing the English Federation. That criticism is, in brief, an