the fact that a hierarchy was not of long duration, and the סופר (Scribe) finally triumphed over the כהן (Priest).
It was Ezra's purpose to make the Law of Moses the guide of the Israelites in their personal, domestic and civil life. Assisted by a number of scribes who were well-versed in the Law, he set out to accomplish this task. His first step was to acquaint the people with the sacred books. The priests alone were hitherto more or less familiar with the laws, especially with those that referred to their immediate duties. This was dangerous. The Law must become the property of all the people. Although a priest himself, Ezra readily gave up his prerogative, knowing that the public weal depended upon that. The Torah was read and explained to large assemblies regularly three or four times during the week; the old Hebrew script in which the Scriptures were written, and which was entirely unknown to the great majority, was now superseded by the more familiar, so called Assyrian script; an attempt was made towards collecting the sacred writings and fixing the canon. Nor was Ezra occupied merely with the compilation and the explanation of the Law. In conjunction with Nehemiah he also labored for the practical application of the Law, and although he met with great opposition on all sides, by his indomitable courage he succeeded in forcing the Jews to live up to the laws and precepts of the Torah.
In 444 B. C. E. Nehemiah called a very large assembly of all the Jews, before whom Ezra read the scroll of the Law. The people then assumed the obligations imposed upon them by the Torah, and about eighty five men signed a document, in which they bound themselves to follow all the commandments of God. According to the Talmud there were one hundred and twenty men; these, according to Krochmal, included thirty five prophets and priests whose names are not mentioned in the book of Nehemiah. This important gathering of Jews was called later “The Great Assembly,” כנסת הגדולה. I say later, for the name does not occur in the book of Nehemiah, nor in any of the later writings (even Josephus makes no mention of it,) until the days of the Mishnah. There is no doubt, however, as to the fact that this body was first convened in the time of Ezra and Nehemiah. But whether this body became a permanent legislative assembly, or was convened for this special occasion only ; who constituted it; how its members were chosen; what was the manner of their procedure and what their au-
thority — all these questions are disputed by the historians, and it is very difficult to decide on account of the meagre facts preserved of that period.
The first Mishnah of Aboth begins with :
“ Moses received the Torah on Sinai and delivered it to Joshua, and Joshua to the elders, and the elders to the prophets, and the prophets delivered it to the men of the Great Assembly; these said three things : Be cautious in pronouncing judgement ; make many disciples ; make a fence around the Torah. Simeon the Just was of the survivors of the Great Assembly.”
From this we infer that the כנסת הגדולה was in existence from this time to the days of Simeon II, (who is considered by the majority of modern historians to be identical with Simeon the Just, Graetz notwithstanding.) who lived about 200 B. C. E., altogether about 244 years. But we are still left in darkness as to the frequency of its meetings, and whether it was a name applied to a body of men, or to a period of time.
The discussion on this subject among Jewish as well as Christian historians began as early as the latter part of the seventeenth century—some denying its existence altogether, others affirming its continued existence for the whole period mentioned above. At present most of the critics follow Kuenen’s view, as expressed in his essay entitled, in the German translation by Buddé, “ Ueber die Maenner der grossen Synagoge.” After an exhaustive investigation of the subject Dr. Kuenen comes to the conclusion that this body never assembled again after the time of Nehemiah, and its name used by the Tanaim was merely a fictitious name applied to the long period of the Sopherim. This view is now accepted by the learned world, and we are thus robbed of the august body, which to the Talmudist represents the height of dignity and to which he attributes the best and noblest in his present-day religion. .
In the current numbers of the ‘“‘ Ha-Shiloah,’’ appears a series of articles on the development of the Talmud, by one who signs himself “ Tal- mudi.”’ In the issue of July, the author takes up the question of the Keneseth Ha-Gedolah, and, it seems to me, throws much light on this otherwise obscure subject. He describes there, very briefly indeed, another institution which existed during the time of Ezra, and of which very little is said by the Jewish historians. This is the institution of the Maamad and Mishmar which is frequently referred to in the Talmud, and which may serve as a clue to a better under-