The Maccabaean · Vol. I, No. 3 · December 1901
XXIIIprinted page
scan 75 of 102
THE MACCABÆAN SUPPLEMENT.
XXIII

demption quite different from that which the believers and hopers in redemption had looked for, and he was rebuked for it. Why, when the prophet proclaimed Cyrus the Messiah of the world, there were plenty of people who scoffed at such a proclamation, and yet was not Cyrus the Messiah? You see this is my answer to orthodoxy. We need not be more orthodox than Isaiah; call him the old Isaiah, I care not,—I claim that the second part of this Isaiah is as Jewish as the first part. The mere fact that we have among the Zionists orthodox, good men, reformers, perhaps more than Isaiah,—if we consider the mass of Jews all over the world; the mere fact that we have leading reformers, and the centre of a leading reform, would be a sufficient refutation of all charges against Zionism.

But we know men cannot decide questions, but principles must, so the question is this—are those who oppose Zionism on the religious or quasi-religious ground, entitled to it? I say positively, no! It has been claimed that we Jews have ceased to be a nation, that we are merely one of the various denominations of the world,—a creed, and not a nation. This is a question that neither I nor you are able to decide on scientific grounds. There are scientists who say that the formation of our skulls proves that we are direct descendants of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. Others say that we have a large admixture of foreign blood and are no longer a pure race. If you will show me a pure race in this world, I will give up and say we are not Jews any more. For there is no pure race. Go to the British Islands, go to the old lords and ask them in confidence, “is your blood perfectly pure?” and they will tell you “not quite beyond all suspicion, there is a little Celtic, Germanic — all kinds of blood in my veins.” There is no pure race, but suppose we are not a pure race,—we are a race. I will ask you, when the word “Jew” is mentioned, whether you feel a palpitation of the heart merely because he is supposed to believe as you do, (maybe he doesn't believe at all), or do you feel that palpitation because it tells you ‘he is my brother,’ not my brother in faith alone, but my brother in blood.

So, whether scientists differ or agree, it makes no difference. I am what I am, I am a Jew; so are you, and so are we. Whether you call it a race, a nation, a people, we are a community — each one of us is a member of a community which, if it stands for anything in the world, stands for the great principle of brotherhood. So

that argument must fall to the ground; on it we cannot build.

But there is another one, the old cry “since you, Moses and Aaron, came to see Pharoah you make our flavor ill-smelling.” That means that your condition among your fellows is in danger. The cry will be raised against you that no Jew can be a patriot in a home which he has chosen, time and time again, and people will say “yes, the anti-Zionists are right, the Jews cannot be good citizens because their eyes are directed towards Zion.” This is an argument, but it is exactly like that raised against Moses and Aaron, and is one which requires weighing. The stranger who has no insight into this movement will, for the moment, be deceived by such a cry, and so when a corporation in this country declares that Washington is our Palestine, and Zion our America, in spite of the mere fact that the part can never be larger than the whole, in spite of the fact that what was said could not be taken literally, still it passed over the country. It was one of those “flying words” passed along. Now what does it mean? In plainer words, you cannot be a patriot if you are a Zionist. When patriotism calls upon citizens of the United States to come forward and defend and free a neighboring people from slavery, we are not found wanting, and when volunteers were called for the Cuban war, two-thirds of the Jews who volunteered their services were Zionists. This should be an evidence of the fallacy of the accusation. But beside this, is it true that a patriot can only have one interest at heart, and that the interest of his country and nothing else? I tell you, at least as far as America is concerned, that that patriot who can have nothing in view but the interest of his own country, is the poorest patriot that ever existed. If patriotism consists in trying to lick somebody — if this is patriotism, (and it seems to be the patriotism that so many nations possess,) then I confess that all of you, myself included, are very, very poor patriots; but if patriotism, especially American patriotism, consists in being the standard bearers of liberty and equality, of being the living proof of how a nation can prosper and progress on the basis of a free opportunity for all alike — then, brethren, you are very good patriots, and so am I. If patriotism consists in being the lovers of him whom Providence has not favored with living offspring in shape of children, but to whom it has given a name and future larger than sons and daughters — if patriotism consists in being intellectual descendants of George Washington, we are pat-