IV.
Addresses.
Dr. Jastrow: "Zionism and its Critics."
WHAT I have to say on Zionism is not so much on the work that has been achieved and accomplished, because of it I know, I am ashamed to say, but very little. I know only this much, that we have set our confidence in the leaders of this movement here and abroad. We must have confidence, we must have implicit confidence in those that have taken the lead and have been called upon by Providence to lead us to success. Unless we have this confidence, we cannot succeed. We may have our private criticism on this and that step taken by Dr. Herzl, but when we meet we must say “they know better than each of us what is to be done.” If we have not that confidence, our cause must fail. It is impossible to initiate every one of us into the steps that are taken by our leaders, and therefore I say I know very little of the work achieved, because at my age, and in my position, I am not able to take an active part. To play only the critic I believe is out of place in a movement like this, in a movement that is called Zionism.
I will, therefore, speak on the nature of Zionism, on its condition in the public mind, how it is received, how it is understood and how it is misunderstood, and what is to be done to remove misunderstanding. There is a rule of Providence that history should, as we often say, repeat itself, that events which we think belong to an ancient past shall again come before us. But this repetition is as the repetition of the view of a winding road. A railroad goes up to the summit of a mountain, but it does not go straight up, it winds around, and twice, thrice, or four times you are on the same spot, it seems; you have the same view below you, and yet it is not the same spot; you are one degree higher than you were a minute before. And so you go on, the winding road leads you to the same point again and
again, but each time a little higher. The past lies before you, beneath you, and you see it again in a different light, but it is the same past you look upon until you reach the summit. This is history.
Now, who, among all nations, has had more repetitions of history than Israel? I will not speak of all the various past events we have gone through, but only of this—the movement of Zionism. It is a very old, old movement. It began thousands of years ago in Egypt, when a certain Moses (I believe you have heard his name before) came with the cry “Let us go that we may serve our Lord,” and I need not tell you there were people opposed to Moses, bitterly opposed. “Why,” they said, “since you, Moses and Aaron, have come before Pharoah, you have made our scent foul in the eyes of Pharoah and the eyes of his servants.” (This is incongruous; you never hear of eyes perceiving a flavor or scent. It is that want of precision you find among those who are in the wrong.) I need not say that the same charge is brought up now: that the Zionistic movement will make us of ill repute with the nations among whom we live. There are various oppositions to Zionism which we may discuss singly.
Orthodoxy is opposed to it. Why? It is not as they imagined the redemption would come. “A Messiah is promised us, the son of David, and we must keep our hands folded, ready for the coming of the Messiah and in the meantime, do nothing.” So says orthodoxy. So said orthodoxy in the days of Cyrus and the Babylonian captivity. Zionism raised its flag and the prophet pronounced the message of Zion, when he said: “On the mountains rise, thou harbinger of Zion, raise thy voice with force, thou harbinger of Jerusalem, and say to the city of Jerusalem: ‘Here is your God.’” He proclaimed a re-
