logically—how can one voluntarily leave a family or a nation in which one has been placed by nature, or, to use a theologic expression, by God? One can free oneself from an association created by men, into which, willingly or unwillingly, one has been received by the act of the association. Not so with the family or the race. Now, since in Israel, race and religion, according to the Talmud and the rabbis, are inseparable, pious, so-called orthodox Jews were forbidden to make an apostate work on the Sabbath or to give or sell him forbidden meat, and so on — for he was a Jew. In the same spirit, if the occasion arose, the apostate Jew had to obtain a document of divorce drawn up according to the law, or he had to take personal part in the procedure for relieving him of a levirate marriage, if the woman in question wished to be recognized as a Gerushah or a Chaluzah. Otherwise, the woman would ever be bound to him, the “Jew.” And other cases might be adduced.
VIII.
And the proselyte, the Ger Zedek? Is he not a Jew, as perfect a Jew as the Jew by birth? No, he is not. To give a brief proof. Suppose it becomes the duty of a Beth Din (a Jewish court of three) in Warsaw or Cracow, or, let us even say, in New York or in Cincinnati, to grant a ritual divorce, or to preside at an act for relieving certain persons from the obligation of a levirate marriage. At the formation of the Beth Din a man is present who is thoroughly versed in Talmudic literature and law, and is strictly orthodox in his mode of life. The presiding rabbi rejects this man, who has been proposed as Dayyan, as a member of the college. “Rabbi Warder Cresson, Junior,” he says, “cannot be associate judge here.” Why not? He is a proselyte. True, he was only a child when his parents were converted to Judaism and he with them; his parents gave him a strictly orthodox education, and had him study Talmudic subjects many years in Yeshibot (Talmudic high schools) of this country and of Poland; he is honored as a faithful Jew, and recognized as a great “Lamdan.” Yet as a Ger, he may not be a Dayyan. No more would such a Ger have been permitted to act as associate judge by the pious rabbi, Jacob Ettlinger of Altona, who so recently as sixty years ago regularly sat in judgment upon civil cases between Jewish litigants. It is a fact not to be gainsaid that proselytes, according to the Halakah, are not qualified to hold any office. Only the full Jew, one whose mother was a Jew by race, could be entrusted with an official position.
In other respects, besides, the proselyte was not on a perfect level with the Jew by race. For instance, certain marriages forbidden the full Jew were permitted the proselyte. This attitude was derived from the Talmudic teaching, קהל גרים לא איקרי קהל, a community of proselytes is not a true community of Jews, not a congregation of God, from which certain elements must be kept aloof. On the other hand a “Cohen” was forbidden to take a proselyte to a wife, and there are more regulations of the same kind. (The rabbis in our country and other learned readers of these theses do not need proofs of the statements I have made; for they know the sources. Other readers may all the more freely accept my statements without corroboration, since the sources, even if given, would probably be inaccessible to them.)
X.
In the course of three or four generations the descendants of apostates, through intermarriage with aliens, naturally step out of the race to which their ancestors belonged. Similarly, the descendants of proselytes, through the intermarriage of their parents with full-blooded Jewesses, become part and parcel of the Jewish race.
XI.
There is an etymologic connection between the German words “Stamm” and “abstammen,” between the Latin words “natus” and “natus,” and, possibly, between the Hebrew words Umma and Em. This is a proof that in deciding the race or nationality of an individual, greatest stress, even in most ancient times, is laid on his descent and not on certain anatomical peculiarities and the like, which he might happen to possess in common with others. In classifying the human species it is not the form of the skull and not the color of the hair that decides, but descent. Who were the parents, and who the ancestors? Granted there are brachycephalic and dolichocephalic, dark-haired and light-haired Jews. But there are Bavarians and Mecklenburgers; yet both belong to the Germans. There are Arabian race-horses, Norman draught-horses, and Scottish ponies—all are horses. Some trees bear sweet cherries, some sour cherries. They are only species of the genus cherries. Sub-species comprised in a higher class unit. If difference of the skull formation provide an argument in favor of the view that the Jews do not form a single unified race, well and good; then we say in order to sat-
