his skepticism; for he must qualify it by the addition: “as far as he can judge at this moment.” But, who can tell what may happen to-morrow or next day? Unless he claims the prophet’s knowledge of the future, he must bow to the truth of the German adage: “Unverhofft kommt oft!” That the Zionist is not an idle dreamer and mere visionary is proved by the fact that he is found active everywhere and eager to spread the new plan of ending the miseries of Israel; that he invites criticism and that he makes the Zionistic idea an incentive to spread light and cheer and help amongst the laboring classes of our people. As a spur to this kind of activity it may already be called a success. And inasmuch as the sufferings of the Jews in Europe, so far from abating in any measurable degree, very clearly grow from bad to worse and no other plan of relief is proposed anywhere, is the Zionist not justified in clinging to the only one which finds a response in thousands of Jewish hearts, and now begins to wring from unwilling but fair-minded men the admission that the only fault to be found with it is : that it is an “ideal.”
But what would man be without ideals? Of all nations, Israel should be the last to be disheartened by that objection; for he has clung to his ideals under trials that have gained 'for him the designation of "the martyred race." And what was the soul of his faith but the hope that he should not perish in his dispersion over the Earth, but return to his forefathers' home and thus be vindicated in the eyes of all the world.
Press Criticism
WE may expect criticism from those of our brethren who wish to forget the fact that they are racial Jews even while they feel within themselves that they are, every inch of them, Jews. That may contradict their sensibilities; it is consistent with their philosophy of life. But it is hardly to be expected that a Jewish press, appealing primarily to a Jewish community, Jewish sentiment, Jewish organization, should treat the Zionist movement with envenomed sarcasm. We ourselves are not prone to exalt everything done by the present Zionist movement; it is not as good as it might be. We, too, know the weaknesses of the propaganda, even better, perhaps, than those who sneer and belittle our efforts. But we, for our part, are hopeful; we have faith in the Jewish people;
we trust that endless stream of Jewish life which has been sustained through the centuries, purging itself naturally of the foulnesses that had accumulated about it as it swept onward. Our friends who set together editorials for the Jewish weeklies, however, lack faith even when they appeal to a Jewish community. They call for charity; charity for whom? For Jews! The Jewish home, the Jewish father, the Jewish child, Jewish hope, Jewish virtue, are terms repeated by them with great unction. The fact of the matter is that all of this is an artificial grimace, and because the writers do not mean what they say, their appeals are ineffectual. They laud the virtues of the Maccabæans, but an imitator of the Maccabees is sneered at. They speak of Jewish valor, but the valiant Jew, who will not take any more crumbs from the table of the world Dives, is spat upon for his obstinacy. They speak of Jewish dignity, but the Jew who would refuse to accept special favors, in Russia, in Roumania, in Germany; the Jew who would stand as a man and if being a man means insult, oppression, to resent it like a man: that Jew is said to arouse anti Semitism.
All of which means that we must either stand by the national movement or give in entirely to our environment. To Rome or Jerusalem; for Judaism or for the religions and customs of our environment.
Success and Failure
WHETHER or no leaders of the Zionist movement are impractical, is immaterial, it seems to us, in considering the value of the movement as an awakener of Jewish life. The present leaders may be "visionaries" and "men who have made failures of their lives;" but at least, the very least of them, the most unworthy of them, have that divine gift of hopefulness, of sentiment, of idealism, which in itself means success in life. For what is this pseudo-success our brethren have established as a criterion of value, but a materialistic notion that has been the bane of Jewish life for centuries past. What is this success but the pursuit of the gross things of life, the coarse worship of gain and the means used to grasp it. Perhaps certain men are failures in life, because what they aspire to is so immense, that they can never gain it. We prefer those who hitch their wagons to stars, to those who clip their own wings for fear of being tempted to soar. And whether the leaders of