The Maccabaean · Vol. I, No. 2 · November 1901
59printed page
scan 3 of 48
Facsimile · scan 3 of 48
Scan of p. 59
Text · transcribed from the scan

whole have been diverted from it. More and more they have been leaving it to scholars to be dissected and analyzed scientifically; less and less they have been impelled by its animating force, and this in spite of the fact that they owe it the position they hold in the world of to-day. They play their honorable and useful part, because they are dowered by ancestral Talmud study with intellectual alertness and spiritual endurance. Freighted with the heritage and trained by the discipline of the East, they have become equal co-workers with the West.

The question arises, and this is the internal Jewish question: How long can the effects of the Talmudic discipline outlast itself? Can the Jew go on forever drawing upon his reserve stock of "Jewishness?" At this point Zionism and its adversaries part company.

The indifferent and the despairing hold that there is no balm in Gilead for the Jewish disease. They interpret Israel's needs as his death-knell. The time has come, they say, for the Jew to permit his personality to be merged in that of the nations with whom he has been a sojourner during the dispersion. He no longer has a mission to proclaim to them. Racially, nationally, and religiously, those who speak thus have become so far estranged from the heart of Judaism that they do not understand the accent of its need.

Others, afflicted with mental myopia and emotional “shortness of spirit,” stand so close to a few of the many aspects of Judaism, that they cannot take in the potentialities of the whole. They maintain, the life led by the Jew during the Talmudic age to be the only possible Jewish life. It keeps the Jew apart and thoroughly Jewish, and at the same time it keeps him in contact with the nations before whom he is to stand as the witness of God. Theoretically there may seem to be other possibilities, but they are so remote from the present-day Jew that they are foregone failures. If the Jew but persists long enough in the effort to revivify the Talmudic life, the olden spirit is bound to return, and the dry bones must live.

Zionism takes an altogether different view of the situation. It is more hopeful: it repudiates the inference from present confusion that the Jew has ceased to be an independent agent of civilization. Though he may no longer be an eloquent witness or a persuasive missionary, Judaism has lost none of its vitality, and he can again become its exponent by living a Jewish life. Yet Zionism is not heedless of facts: it sees and frankly

acknowledges the need of the Jew to undergo a process of rejuvenation from which he shall emerge a Jew — a Jew with Jewish ideals and Jewish aspirations drawn from the very source of Judaism. And Zionism is more resourceful and more energetic: it will not accept Talmudism as the exclusively normal and as the final Jewish state; it discerns other possibilities, and is prepared to try them.

Zionism is not only hopeful, not only alive to existing conditions, resourceful, and energetic; it is also practical, and never more so than when it resorts to the Talmudic age for instruction.

The Talmudic age was ushered in by one of the most notable struggles recorded in history, the resistance offered to Rome by the Jewish Commonwealth. Could the Jews assume that their dispersion was the will of Providence until they had taken every step to avert what in their human judgment seemed inevitable ruin? To-day human judgment tells the Jew that he has before him national dissolution, national stagnation, or national rehabilitation. When he succumbs in the struggle for the last, then Zionism will believe that the Jew must submit passively to one of the other two fates, accepting it as the decree of God.

Another lesson Zionism has learned from the example of the Talmudic age. The Diaspora was not preserved by a force of itsown. The stream of salvation flowed down the ages from the central points of Jewish nationality in Palestine, the schools established long before the final catastrophe and the school established when the catastrophe was seen to be inevitable. Again, strong asthe national impetus was that issued from these original centres, it would have grown sluggish, if subsidiary centres had not formed themselves from time to time, first in Babylonia, then in Africa, in Spain, in France, in Italy, in Germany, and in Poland. Where the most original and abundant Talmud work was done, there for the time was the centre of Judaism, with that country rested the Jewish hegemony, thither resorted in person or by letter all aspiring Jewry.

It is only since the other day that no such dominating Jewish centre has existed — since democracy has been in the ascendent, while the Jewish democracy has been steadily losing its cohesion. In the disorganized condition of the Jewish people, the very circumstances of modern life that are calculated to diffuse knowledge and all good — rapid means of communication and