The Maccabaean · Vol. I, No. 2 · November 1901
89printed page
scan 33 of 48
Facsimile · scan 33 of 48
Scan of p. 89
Text · transcribed from the scan

sion which filled his latter days with its stupendous adumbration and vanished so tragically with his early death — it is impossible to doubt . . . Cromwell’s statecraft was, as I have said, not entirely or even essentially governed by religious policy. He desired to make England great and prosperous, as well as pious and free, and for these purposes he had to consider the utility of his subjects even before he weighed their orthodoxy. Now the Jews could not but appeal to him as very desirable instruments of his colonial and commercial policy. . . ”

Menasseh's writings are well worth reading for their quaintness and Messianic leanings. His writings were destined to serve the Zionists of the seventeenth century, who looked to England as their Palestine and to London as their Jerusalem, for the great Continental Mizraim. Although Menasseh is but the puppet in Cromwell's hands, he is nevertheless considered to have been the leader of the fight for the Return, and with this idealized position in the Anglo-Jewish community, he has been remembered by posterity.

In conclusion, then, we cannot but praise Mr. Wolf's scholarly edition of Menasseh. It is an exhaustive study within limits, and should be supplemented now, as we have already stated, by a biography of the chief actor.

S. M. FRIEDENBURG.

Die Blutanklage und sonstige Mittelalterische Beschuldigungen der Juden. Eine historische Untersuchung nach den Quellen, von Dr. D. Chwolson. Translated from the Russian, in agreement with the second corrected and amended edition, 1880, with additions and corrections by the author (German). Frankfort a. M.: J. Kauffmann.

There is no need at present to speak any additional word of commendation of Dr. Chwolson's painstaking and admirable work on the Blood Accusation. It has been accepted as the most convincing contribution on this very stubborn question, which has ever appeared. The inception of the work dates back to 1857 when Doc-

tor Chwolson became interested in the subject on being asked for an opinion by the Russian government on a case which had arisen in Saratow, on the Volga, in which instance a number of Jewish soldiers, stationed away from their homes, were charged with bleeding two Christian children for ritual purposes. In arriving at his decision, Dr. Chwolson traversed a field of historic investigation never before considered so comprehensively, and, being well prepared for his task, aided by all the facilities of the libraries of his country and elsewhere, the work he has produced stands as a monument to his erudition, thoroughness, and fair mindedness.

The subject is divided into two parts, the one being an investigation of the accusation that Jews need blood for religious purposes, the other that they require it in incantations, medicinal experiments, and for other superstitious needs. It is needless to state what conclusions the learned author arrives at. In a preface to this German translation, dated 1901, Dr. Chwolson says that he once thought the accusation a phenomenon to be found in half-civilized countries, but that since then he has had good reason for changing his mind. In Germany, he remarks, a country where education is general, of the highest culture, the accusation was twice brought against the Jews near the end of the XIXth century. Such an incident he had considered unthinkable and he comes to the conclusion that that which is called culture, i. e., the possession of a certain modicum of knowledge, in and by itself is not true culture, which of truth is the soul of morality and involves the effort for the attainment of the ideal excellences. And this culture is no more to be found now than in the dark years of the Middle Ages.

The fact that such a volume as this has been written and circulated, that its arguments have been repeated in various countries and on various occasions, indicates that the prejudice rests on no factual foundation whatsoever, that it cannot be attacked, with any hope of success, by the use of logic or rational argument.