The Maccabaean · Vol. I, No. 2 · November 1901
58printed page
scan 2 of 48
58
THE MACCABÆAN.
[November, 1901.

Jewish mind is alive to the problems of modern society, it serves only as a suggestion of the pitfalls the Jewish State will encounter in endeavoring to reconcile latter-day perplexities with the directness of ancient Jewish law, with its stern denunciation of usurious encroachment by capital, with its unsophisticated solution of the property difficulties of Zelophchad's daughter. And where is the guileless Zionist who would dare point, by way of refutation, to the political achievements of Moses, David, Solomon, and Ezra? On all sides he would be pierced with historical taunts read as prophecies: how again and again the people rebelled under Moses, even in the wilderness, where they must still have remembered vividly that God Himself, upon eagle's wings, had borne them away from Egyptian oppression; how the prowess of David had served to call down upon the Israelites bloody wars with the neighboring nations; how Solomon's glory and pomp had been a shining veil under which teemed the corruption that divided the kingdom after his death, and bred a progeny of evils ending only with the extinction of the First Commonwealth; and how Ezra's strenuous Judaic spirit conjured up the sceptre of religious strife, and sowed the seed of dissension in almost every Jewish home.

That much of this argumentation is specious, giving prominence only to the facts that favor doubt of Jewish ability to organize and govern, could easily be shown, if it were worth while. We can afford to disregard it, for Zionism rests its case, not upon what some Jews have or have not done, but upon what all Jews may do by reason of the progressiveness, the native forces, the potentialities of Judaism.

If Zionism had but one Jewish question to solve, the external one—the question created by anti-Semitism and industrial and economic disturbances, then the solution it proposes, the re-establishment of the Jewish life for the Jew, might well awaken misgivings. An impulse shaped by such accidental considerations might bring together irreconcilable elements not to be fused into a national unit.

Besides the external Jewish question, there is an internal one, the Jewish question created by the needs of the Jew as such, the question of national dissolution or of continued existence, together with the terms on which continued existence will be a blessing to the race and to mankind.

It has become almost an axiom with the reader of Jewish history, that the construction and ela-

boration of the Talmudic system has been the vital principle of Jewish longevity. In obedience to a trustworthy instinct, the Diaspora disregarded the ordinary laws of organization. The Jews would have suffered more than they did, had they not appeared weak collectively. To escape annihilation they had to forego every endeavor to hold themselves together as a nation by means of external bonds. Parallel with the need for such caution ran the intense desire to remain a unit. National ingenuity, unconsciously elaborating a plan of safety, pushed into the foreground a factor peculiarly Jewish. Wherever the Jew may have been, his Talmudic education identified him with the Jew in every other part of the world. While he was drinking in the cultures of Spain and the Arabs, of France, Italy, and Germany, he was counteracting, by doses of the Talmud,—an extract from his very own flesh and bones,—whatever anti-Jewish elements the foreign civilizations held in solution. So effectual was the Talmudic discipline, that in spite of the self-effacement he has had to practice, and the external and internal disintegrating influences to which he has been exposed, the Jew is as certainly a Jew now as he was at the beginning of the dispersion.

For two thousand years these disciplinary tactics were successful. To-day, however, he who runs may read that the Talmudic inspiration has lost itself like a river in a sandy waste. The bond of fifty generations has been ruptured, no one knows how, and twentieth century Israel is left without a national anchor: “All we, like sheep, have gone astray; we have turned every one to his way.” Because they realize and deplore the state of affairs, the opponents of Zionism are willing to concede spirituality to the movement they condemn. Spiritual they must, indeed, acknowledge it to be, when in the place of the indifference and the wordy disunion of yesterday, they to-day see national feeling revive at the call of Zionism, and Hebrew language and literature resuscitate under its touch.

Not that the possibilities of the Talmud have been exhausted, not that it has yielded up all its secrets valuable to the sciences, not that its store of ethics has been consumed or its principles superseded. So little is this true that after fifteen hundred years of its study, the Jews, eminent for their ability as translators, have not succeeded in putting it into a modern or into any other language to their own Hebraic satisfaction. To be mindful of its unexplored regions does not contradict the patent fact that the people on the