Emil G. Hirsch and Zionism
Dr. Emil G. Hirsch, of Chicago, has not beenin warm sympathy with the Zionist movement.In fact he has always been a stern critic of theprinciples upon which the propaganda is based.He has rested, with frequent lapses from consistency, on the assumption that Judaism is aworld religion which is destined to conquer theopposing forces about us by means of its inherentgrandeur, its sublime theistic principles, etc. Hislatest utterance on the question dear to Zionistswill be read with more than ordinary interest.Writing in the “ Reform Advocate ” of October19th on the declaration of Mr. Zangwill that asurprise is in store for Jews and non-Jews alikewhen certain news will be made public at thecoming Zionist Congress, Dr. Hirsch observesthe following :
"Will now the Zionists proceed from theoryto practice? If they will, and the long night ofpersecution will show the first rift of faithful hope,we and many others of doubters shall changefrom criticism to co-operation, though we shallstill be skeptics on the score of Zionism's abilityto redeem every one of its promises.
“We fervently pray that this good news will turn out to be true. Nothing will more speedily convert opponents than a practical demonstration of the practicability of the Zionist program. Theoretical opposition cannot continue to urge its arguments in face of even one tangible and happy result of this frothy or furious agitation. Many of us, we are open to say, have been on the other side of the house for no other reason than that we doubted the likelihood of ever anything eventing [?] from this crusade. A wordy passionate, or if you so please, an enthusiastic and idealistic rehearsal of the injustices under which the majority of the Jews have been compelled to eke out a miserable existence, struck us as of no profit as long as no assured way was shown out of this Egypt and its horrors. We also feared that such agitation, raising hopes which in the nature of things as, we dreaded, could not be redeemed, would ultimately prove of frightful harm. The disappointed millions would feel their misfortune finally all the more keenly for having for a term of years been led to credit that there was before them a sure path for escape and to liberty. We were in the opposition though fully aware of the fact that we had no infallible alternative to offer. But we were not convinced that the pessimism which suggested the permanency of present political and social conditions, was irrefutable.
“However desperate the situation, we would not subscribe to the doctrine that as long as the Jew remained in the western countries his lot never would be other than it is now. This pessimism always struck as a natural recoil from and reaction upon, the ever-confident optimism
of former decades. We had indeed sung too soon of the advent of the era of universal brotherood. Our pulpits had rung too often the changes on the one theme so dear to the heart of modern liberalism, the emancipation of the human race from error, sin, hatred, prejudice and what not. In the intoxication of our phraseology we had lost the power to distinguish between the struggling ray of the uncertain dawn and the glory of the noontide flush of solar light. Because we desired to believe our dreams had come to pass, we declared them to have found fulfillment. In the meantime, though we continued blind to the reaction, a misapplied natural philosophy on the one hand and the iron political international diplomacy on the other, had been at work setting to naught the overweaning predictions and dogmatic assumptions of the rhapsodizing humanitarians. This humanitarianism had too much neglected to remember historical facts and forces. The disenchantment was bound to come. It has come. But to him who had an open eye for the working of historical impulses the revival of brutal nationalism the world over was not unexpected.
National sentiment, the feeling of a peculiar and specialized community of spirit and aspiration, has recently received additional expression. The spirit of cosmopolitanism evolved at the beginning of this century is giving way to a universal appreciation of the spirit of nationalism which permits both variety and community of interests in the peoples of the world. On this point Dr. Hirsch says :
"Even the preachment of racial antipathies, which philosophers would have us accept as ineradicable and therefore as the prime moving impulses of what we style history and civilization, was not a surprise. This pessimism which succeeded our optimism was by us from the very first recognized as under the same exaggeration as had been the overconfidence in the efficacy of liberal shibboleths and vapid phraseology which it came to replace. Applying this suspicion to the arguments of the Zionists, we and many more would not subscribe to their fundamental thesis that there was but one salvation for us, viz. : to throw up the sponge and to agree to the central contention of our enemies that the Jew as Jew has no place in the modern world unless he be constituted again a nation apart from the nations of the earth, in a home legally under international sanctions secured for him and his forever. This acceptance of the creed of modern nationalism based on racial affinities was to our mind the saddest feature of the Zionist philosophy and its propaganda."
"But if now the Zionists show us that theyhave not merely been theorizing, that, on thecontrary, their program is feasible to whateversmall extent, all our theoretical opposition willcease. We shall heartily co-operate. In viewof the difficulties arising out of the intolerableinjustice and inhumanity of Russia and Roumania, of Galicia and other dark places in Christen-
