The Maccabaean · Vol. I, No. 1 · October 1901
9printed page
scan 7 of 54
October, 1901.]
THE MACCABÆAN.
9

reach your goal immediately; but the very expectation of your future lot and your active preparation for it will lighten your present misery."

It is evident that the same words cannot be addressed to the Jews of the West. They feel very ill at ease, but they do not care to understand the causes of their discomfort. Anti-Semitism does, indeed, somewhat embitter their existence; but they console themselves with the belief that it is a passing cloud. In all the countries of the Occident, Judaism has its benevolently disposed counselors, who recommend an unfailing remedy against this malignant disease of the time, anti-Semitism. In Germany the worthy Benedictus Levita proposes that the Jews should have their children baptized, if it so be that this treatment is disagreeable to the adults. In France the learned M. S. Reinach, in a Jewish official organ supported by the Consistory, advised the Jews to eat swine’s flesh, which, he says, is much cheaper than the meat of the ritually slaughtered ruminants. In this way they would be better equipped against the competition of the Christian laborer: they would work themselves out of their present poverty into a condition of prosperity, — and, as we all know, well-to-do Jews do not suffer from anti-Semitism. For such, it is proper to add, is the personal experience of the writer of this profound bit of advice, a millionaire twenty times over. In England Mr. Oswald John Simon and Mr. Claude Montefiore preach a progressive development of the Jewish creed into pure theism and ethics, which will necessarily make it the religion of the cultivated and the enlightened the world over. By this means all opposition and difference between Jew and Christian will of itself fade away. In America the reform rabbis are setting to work to carry out this prudent scheme. In Italy theory is abandoned, and the matter is approached practically. Here the correct and gratifying solution to the Jewish question is intermarriage. In the so called “good” families, it has even become a principle to marry the children only to Christians.

All these specifics, although differing from one another and more or less pretentious, have one thing in common, thât they aim at the dissolution of Judaism.

What can Zionism offer such Jews, who at best regard their Judaism as a burden, and frequently as a disgrace ; who think of their parents and ancestors only to chafe because they did not have the sense to undergo baptism thirty or three hundred years ago, and by their loving care remove the anti-Semitic thorns from the path of

the present generation. A dialogue between Zionism and Jews of this stamp would run somewhat as follows:

"Zionism is the only means for preserving Judaism."

"That is the very fault we find with it. We do not want Judaism to be preserved; we want it to disappear."

"Zionism guarantees the Jewish race a future and dignity as a nation."

"Nonsense. There is no Jewish nation ; there is only a Jewish religion, and with that we don't concern ourselves. Our Jewish past and present is enough of an annoyance to us; what should we want with a Jewish future? No, thanks ! National dignity? Is the old clothes trade to become an ideal occupation? Is the Jewish sing-song to reach the aristocratic distinction of the military snarl? Are the splay foot and the hooked nose to be the models of manly beauty? We don't believe in such a shifting about of values, and we don't want to do it. We know of no other national traits in Judaism than these. At least the comic papers, the music hall songs, the broad farces, and the " Dresdener Bilderbogen," from which we draw our knowledge of Judaism, do not speak of others. "

"Zionism makes freemen and citizens of the Jewish helots."

"Legally that's what we already are; and that's what we shall be socially, as well, when we have completely sloughed our Judaism, or hidden it so skilfully that even the anti-Semites cannot scent it out."

“Zionism gives the Jewish proletariat, the most miserable, unfortunate proletariat, a sound basis, on which its energy can successfully exert itself.”

“What’s all this gibberish? There is no Jewish proletariat. We are getting along very nicely, and whoever wants to work is able to spin silk more easily in Germany, France, etc. . . than in the wildernesses of Palestine or other beautiful places far off in Turkey, where nations fight with one another.”

It is not necessary to continue this dialogue. It turns about in a circle, and gets no farther. In fact, it cannot get any farther. Zionism is a matter of reason in the same degree as the geometry of Euclid, which has postulates incapable of demonstration. In the same way Zionism has a postulate beyond the reach of reasonable proof, because it lies in the region of feeling. Zionism presupposes Jewish sentiment, pride in the history of the Jews, the desire for the further histor-