What a vast range of human thought lies between Nachmanides and Moses Hess! Think of the distance of time and space that separates David Reubeni from Max Nordau and the immense difference in conceptions of life of Rabbi Hirsch Kalischer and Dr. Theodor Herzl! And yet, when discussing the bitter lot of their people, they arrived at the same conclusion, each from his own standpoint: The restoration of Israel is its only salvation. ! הַלֹּא רַבְרְבָה הָאֵל
If any conclusion at all is to be derived from the historical data so ingeniously collected by Professor Deutsch, it is this: Zionism is a movement which is traditionally Jewish to the core, and is supported by the logical conclusions of the great minds of many centuries.
LEON ZOLOTKOFF.
American Rabbis and Zionism
WE do not attribute much importance to the reference to Zionism made in his annual report by the President of the Central Conference of American Rabbis. That reference was subsequently—in the course of debate—so qualified by its author as to make it practically of no value aside from its official import. But we do attribute some significance to the fact that rabbis who were formerly strenuously opposed to every phase of national Judaism, diligently asserting their “cosmopolitan prophetism,” listened patiently to a discussion on Zionism and did not rule it out for order; in fact, pled for freedom of debate on the question. Why did not this representative reform organization reiterate its position, its “Washington and Jerusalem” slogan, in view of the presentation of the subject by its president. Was it because it was satisfied that it had established a Judaism minus nationalism? Evidences of reaction by its constituency in the way of emphasizing national holidays would indicate the contrary. Was it because it believed that the previous convention utterance had bound it? Obviously not, for the Conference believes that each Convention has absolute power over its own opinions, limited only by its constitution.
The Conference was silent and neglected to express an opinion because its members felt that the nationalist sentiment—cosmopolitanism tothe contrary— was worthy of at least silence; it had keft its antagonistic position so far that it had reached the neutral state of silence. It seemed to understand that the movement stands for a thoroughly Jewish Sentiment, which can not be decried without at the same time frowning down
that Judaism to which they were bound in devout allegiance. In other words, the Conference, hitherto decidedly opposed to Zionism, at its last meeting had progressed to neutrality.
“Yodea Lishol”
Query I.—Why is it that Christians show so little interest in Zionism? All orthodox creeds teach, as part of their creed, the return of the Jews to Palestine and the revival of the ancient state. They severely censure the reformers for denying that such a future is in store for Israel. Many sects there are which hold that the consummation of Christianity by the reappearance on earth of its originator and the beginning of the millenium depend upon the ingathering of God’s people to the land of their fathers. It might, therefore, be supposed that the believers in the millennial theory would greet with satisfaction the news that a longing for the old home has seized many Jewish hearts and that earnest efforts are being made to satisfy them, and that they would lend their aid to such a movement. But as far as I know no such interest has been manifested. Is it the old experience over again that Israel must put his trust in God and his own determination alone, in this effort to plant the banner of Juda on the hill of Zion and gather around it those whom the rulers of the earth still treat as outcasts ?
How to Organize Zionist Societies
THERE are two ways of organizing a Zionist society. One is the right way. The other is the wrong way. The first is diametrically opposed to the second.
This is the wrong way:
Three or four ardent Zionists meet, rent a hall,prepare circulars, and hold a mass meeting. Aftervery enthusiastic speeches, applications for membership are received. When a sufficient numberof names have been secured, the meeting is adjourned. At another meeting, called in a careless manner, more enthusiastic speeches andvague talk of organization, dues, meetings, butdefinite arrangements, however, as to election ofofficers. When an Executive Committee hasbeen appointed, the rank and file become utterlyindifferent and resort to criticism of officers asthe natural order of business. Then there isvague gossip of joining a vaguely defined Federation. When a circular is received from the