The Maccabaean · Vol. I, No. 1 · October 1901
40printed page
scan 38 of 54
Facsimile · scan 38 of 54
Scan of p. 40
Text · transcribed from the scan

Queries and Answers

[This department is open to all readers of THE MACCABÆAN. It is necessary that questions be legibly written in English, brief and to the point. Correspondents desirous of answering queries must use the “Correspondence” department. Address communications to the Query Editor, 820 Broadway, N. Y. City.]

A ROCHESTER friend writes to inquire what is the population of Jewish colonists in Palestine. According to the very reliable Calendar issued by A. M. Duncz, "Literarischer Palæstina-Almanach fuer das Jahr 5662 (1901-02)," published in Jerusalem, the population of the colonies is 1205 families, or 4935 souls in all. The population of Jews in Jerusalem is estimated at over 30,000 persons.

"M. G. T." of Detroit asks, how can speakers be secured for the Zionist societies of his city. It is impossible to answer the question in the abstract. A letter addressed to the Secretary of the Federation will give information to the effect, we believe, that the date and the ability of the society to defray the proportion of the expense 'of a speaker must be known before any thing can be done. We advise writing to the Chairman of the Propaganda Committee, Dr. S. Mosessohn, 205 Henry St., New York City.

A CONSCIENTIOUS Zionist of St. Louis asks a very delicate question which we must answer vaguely. It is well not to give the facts. In reply we would say that truth is the first consideration. If a member of an organization has sinned, that sin must not be disguised. The erring member must not be permitted to continue in the belief that his wrong-doing is not wrong doing. But if the standing of the organization will be affected by the publicity given to the wrong done, it is much better to adjudicate matters without the intervention of the tribunals established by society. Therefore our advice : Truth, tempered with discretion.

MANUEL MILLER, 311 Henry St., N. Y.: "Is it possible for a Zionist to send his shekel-tax direct to Vienna, without calling on the services of the Federation." At present there is nothing to prevent the sending of money by any individual direct to Vienna, but in the event of the passage of the amendment which it is proposed to introduce in the 5th International Congress the financial relation of individuals and societies with headquarters must be through the medium of the Federation established in each country.

"G. G." propounds the following query and answers it: Query, What is an Anarchist? A person who believes that the whole present social and political order is wrong from beginning to end, so wrong that it cannot be set right by any improvements which even the wisest and justest of men may suggest or attempt; that nothing, therefore, remains for the lovers of the people but to destroy that order and—well, here my pen is arrested, for I never could learn what Anarchism proposes to place instead of the existing order. If they were mere theorisers one might venture to leave them to themselves and trust to time to open their minds to more rational counsels. But they are not; they try to put their theories into practise, and the instrument they use for "breaking a road" is the murderer's weapon. The American people is at this moment horror-stricken at the dastardly deed of one of their number, and ask themselves with despairing looks: What is to be done?

It occurred to me: How is it that so dangerous a part of the inhabitants of our land is left to its own devices and no attempt is made to convert it? The Christian Churches send missionaries to distant lands, at great expense, where the lives of the rulers are much safer than in Christendom and where the social order, though yet in a very primitive state, is generally satisfactory to all classes.