The Maccabaean · Vol. I, No. 1 · October 1901
34printed page
scan 32 of 54
34
THE MACCABÆAN.
[October, 1901.]

The Jewish Historico-Critical School of the Nineteenth Century. By Nathan Stern, A. M. New York, 1901.

This volume of eighty-two pages is the thesis submitted by Mr. Stern as partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy at Columbia University. It contains an introduction and ten chapters treating of the life and work, briefly summarized, of the following noted men* in Jewish scientific work: Nachman Krochmal, Solomon Judah Rapoport, Isaac Samuel Reggio, Samuel David Luzzatto, Leopold Zunz, Abram Geiger, Zacharias Frankel, the anniversary of whose birth is being celebrated this month; Isaac Marcus Jost, Heinrich Graetz, and Moritz Steinschneider to whom the honor is given of being the only living representative of that school of giants produced by the German States. If one may offer a criticism to this thesis it may be in the way of an objection to the seeming indifference, in the author's introduction, to the status of scientific investigation in parts other than Germany. Too much influence is attributed to the German-Jewish reformation and not any to the state of culture in Russia in the seventies, to give but one instance. Mr. Stern's observations on the works of the writers whom he considers are marked by good judgment and agreement with accepted authority.

The American Jewish Year Book. Edited by Cyrus Adler, Ph. D. Philadelphia, Jewish Publication Society of America.

The history of the Jews in Romania by Dr. E. Schwartzfeld is the most important of the valuable articles contained in the Year Book of 1901-2. The story Dr. Schwartzfeld tells has been told before in press despatches and tales by emigrants, but never with the official verification of statute and ordinance. That the Berlin

Treaty is being violated is not being denied by the faithless and ungrateful country which is now persecuting the Jews with shameless audacity. But here we are informed of violations of the commonest rules of social conduct, for which there can be no justification on any ground. Dr. Schwartzfeld of all men is fully competent to write of Roumania, having lived and suffered there in common with his brethren.

Mr. Hermalin does justice to his barren theme by trying to give the history of Roumanian Jewish life in New York city. There is practically no Roumanian Jewish life in this country which can be distinguished with any definiteness from the rest of the Jewish community. The Roumanian Immigrant Aid Society and a few benevolent organizations with distinctly Roumanian constituencies will not make a community of them. As well try to separate the Russian from the Polish element, which is well nigh impossible. Still, Mr. Hermalin's account is very entertaining.

The record of congregations, giving income, officers, etc., has been wisely omitted, and instead, a summary of congregational life has been compiled, which, in a way, is more interesting to the general reader. A few people may object to this omission ; for instance, publishers of Jewish books, officers of national organizations, etc.

The review of the year is able and comprehensive, being a record of nearly everything of importance done during the year. The following reference is made to Zionism:

"The Zionist movement has proceeded on the lines of previous years, strengthening itself in various countries by better methods of organization and by adopting the "cultur" program in addition to that of simple agitation for the original Zionist propositions.