The Maccabaean · Vol. I, No. 1 · October 1901
33printed page
scan 31 of 54

Book Reviews

A Rabbi's Impressions of the Oberammergau Play. By Joseph Krauskopf, D. D. Philadelphia, Edward Stern and Company.

If Dr. Krauskopf's very interesting book were written for Christians, no fault could be found with it. It is a very forceful argument against the traditional Jesus. It is also an indictment of the Oberammergau play as the disseminator of that incorrect and vicious story which many accept as truth. But the position Dr. Krauskopf takes will not commend itself to Jews. They will find much that is distasteful in the book. The author is too fond of complaining of the lack of appreciation of the Jew. "Let the Jew but tell his story" and the world will open its arms to him. This attitude reminds one of certain Socialists who believe that if only Socialism were expounded fully, and the world could be made to listen, it would at once be universally accepted. It is also the assumption of the orthodox Christian, who believes the mere telling of the story of the vicarious atonement must impel belief. Undoubtedly appreciation of the Jew is desirable. But it is abhorrent to our dignity as men to appeal for appreciation. We for our part prefer to rest in the belief that "Truth crushed to earth will rise again," and that not only is it foolish and useless to cringe and plead, but it is contrary to that dignity of manhood which we cannot forego even for the world's appreciation.

The prejudice against the Jew, if based on reason, can have only selfish motives behind it. It cannot be dislodged by any argument but one based on the plea of greater gain. Logic that shows inconsistency in reasoning will not convince. The Oberammergau play, in our opinion, does not perpetuate any prejudice. It is the expression of a prejudice.

Les Juifs en Roumanie Depuis le Traite de Berlin jusqu'a ce jour. Par Edmond Sincerus (Dr. E. Schwartzfeld). London and New York, The Macmillan Company.

This is a book of authortiative weight. It is the most important and comprehensive volume

yet published on the Roumanian persecution. It begins with the Berlin Treaty, which, though not marking the beginning of Roumanian Jewish persecution, yet is the dividing line between despotic and governmental injustice and direct violation of treaty agreement. The author is thoroughly at home in contemporary history and utilizes with much skill the data at hand. His style is terse, direct and very eloquent.

All phases of the legal restriction of the Jews, with reference to trade and the professions, are enumerated and discussed. Of course, all laws against the Jews are really laws against strangers, which the Jews, by the most palpable falsehood, are charged with being. On this point Dr. Schwartzfeld brings documentary evidence to prove the presence of Jews in Roumania and the surrounding provinces. They were settled in Wallachia in 1367, a short time after the founding of the principality by Ladislas Bassarab. In Roumania Jews were found at the beginning of the 16th century, at which time they occupied the position of entrepreneurs in many industries. A document dated 1574 shows that they lived in Moldavia under Roman I. (1391-1394) and Alexander the Good (14011433). Many of them lived in the capital of Moldavia, Suceava, under Etienne the Great, when they are heard of as cattle dealers. The other objection, as to their numbers, is also shown to be based on fictitious statistics and exaggerations.

It is unnecessary to review the objections made against the presence of Jews in Roumania. It can all be reduced to wilful injustice and a desire to eliminate the Jewish population from the country. The remedy for the sad plight of the Jews, which is destined to be aggravated in the future, can be drawn from the last remark of the author of this work, in which he says that they are treated as "strangers without being entitled to that protection which the stranger usually possesses." That is, they are strangers without a country to come to their rescue when they are unjustly treated.