tax cannot be imposed on a foreigner, discrimination based on religious grounds, affecting hisperson, are certainly illegal.
Not only is a law directed against a certain class null and void, but any personal restrictions that do not operate uniformly in all parts of the empire or nation cannot be used against citizens who come from treaty-related nations.
The case of Mr. Joseph B. Walsh may be cited. Mr. Walsh was a citizen of the United States who was arrested and imprisoned in Dublin, March 3, 1881, in accordance with a provision of the Act of Parliament known as the "Protection Act." Mr. Blaine's instructions to Mr. Lowell, Ambassador to England, June 2, 1881, were as follows: "I have already indicated to you the entire absence of any disposition on the part of this Government to interfere with the administration of the local or general municipal laws of Great Britain . . . But whatever the necessity may be in the estimation of her Majesty's Government for the existence and enforcement in Ireland of the exceptional legislative measures recently enacted in respect to that country, this Government cannot view with unconcern the application of these measures to naturalized citizens of the United States of Irish origin."
Mr. Freylinghuysen's instructions to Mr. Morgan, Minister to Mexico, July 24, 1882, may be added. These instructions were given with reference to the Mexican system of matriculation, that is, of registration by foreigners of their names, which was detrimental to the interests of naturalized Americans who returned to their native country, Mexico. Mr. Freylinghuysen said: "We hold under the general principles of international law that the right of an American citizen to claim protection of his own Government while in a foreign land and the duty of the Government to exercise such protection, are reciprocal and are inherent in the allegiance of the citizen under the constitution of his own land, and that, inasmuch as this reciprocal right on the part of the citizen and duty on the part of his Government, is not created by the laws of any oreign country, it cannot on the other hand be denied by the municipal law of a foreign state. . . . I repeat, the status of a foreigner is, under international law, inherent and neither created nor destroyed by Mexican law."
This statement may be taken as the princ ple -national law. It means that no muni-
cipal law can so act as to thwart the intent or purpose of any treaty stipulation; and, moreover, no domestic law can be enacted and enforced that assumes to interfere or dictate to another nation the making or unmaking of its citizens.
The right of an American Jewish citizen in Palestine has been clearly established and rests on the general principles of international law and, more specially, on the Turkish laws that exempt foreigners from the operation of municipal or local law in all matters except with relation to real estate. There can be no objection, however, to a law intended merely as a regulation. For example : Demanding a passport in order to ascertain the foreigner's nationality, or a domestic pass to travel through the country. But there must be no distinction made between subjects and foreigners.
Hence, American Jews who intend to travel or establish themselves in Palestine must abide by the general rules that govern other American citizens. These rules are given by Dr. Selah Merrill, Consul at Jerusalem, October 21, 1899, as follows:
"Passports are required of every traveller visiting Palestine, which, in case of Americans, must be vised by some Turkish Consul before leaving America, otherwise a fine of two dollars is imposed by the officials at Jaffa. If a traveler comes without a passport, he is subjected to a fine of about four dollars, which sometimes the Consul succeeds in having remitted. If the traveler wishes to visit the interior of the country, say to go overland from Jerusalem to Damascus and Beirut, he must procure from the Turkish Government, through the United States Consul, a Turkish passport (Teskereh). If a person wishes to go direct from Jerusalem to Beirut, his Teskereh must indicate the fact, and in Beirut his Teskereh must be vised by the Turkish authorities for his return trip; otherwise there is another fine."
Now, to sum up.
American citizens in Turkey, under the treaty of 1830, enjoy all the privileges accorded citizens of the most favored nations, and under the protocol of 1874 may acquire and hold real estate in Ottoman territory. All attempts by the Turkish authorities to nullify the treaty of 1830 or to abridge American rights have been futile, as the following cases, in addition to what has been said above, show: Damages suffered by the Rev. George C. Knapp, arising out of a real estate