The Maccabaean · Vol. I, No. 1 · October 1901
29printed page
scan 27 of 54
October, 1901 ]
THE MACCABÆAN.
20

to the State Department, August 7, 1885, by Mr. Heap, consul general at Constantinople. An order was issued from Safed, Palestine, expelling two American Jewish citizens, Louis Lubrowsky and brother, because of their religious faith. It appears that on their arrival at Safed, these brothers were required either to give bonds in the sum of 400 Turkish pounds or leave the country in ten days or obtain a special license to remain. Mr. Heap instructed Mr. Robeson, the nearest consul, stationed at Beirut, to advise the Lubrowsky brothers not to yield to the order unless force were employed. This action of Mr. Heap Mr. Bayard approved as "discreet and proper."

It is submitted that Mr. Bayard erred when he declared that comity and friendship alone entitled the United States to ask that no distinction be made in the treatment between Christian and Jewish citizens abroad. It was also an international legal right, as the following will show.

Article IX of the Treaty of Paris, March 30, 1856, as modified by the Treaty of London of March 13, 1871, signatories to which were their Majesties, the Queen of England, the Emperor of France, the Czar of Russia and the Sultan of Turkey, reads as follows : — "His Imperial Majesty, the Sultan, having in his constant solicitude for the welfare of his subjects issued a Firman which, while ameliorating their condition, without distinction of religion or of race, records his generous intention toward the Christian population of his Empire and wishing to give a further proof of sentiments in that respect, has resolved to communicate to the Contracting Parties the said Firman emanating spontaneously from his Sovereign will."

The Firman, it will be observed, gives equal religious rights to all Turkish subjects, including Christians and Jews, and as proof of that fact, the Powers obtained the Sultan's communication to that effect, of which the United States has a right to take advantage.

Hence, by granting religious liberty to his own subjects, by inference including his Jewish subjects, the Sultan could not discriminate against American Jews on the score of their religion, for in that case, his own Jewish subjects would be more favored than American citizens of the same faith.

Moreover, the Turkish government has conceded that foreigners are not amenable to its local or municipal laws, by the special law it has enacted, regulating the right to hold real estate in Turkey.

For Article II of the Imperial Iradé, dated January 18, 1867, provides that “Foreigners, proprietors of real estate in town or in country, are placed on terms of equality with Ottoman subjects in all things that concern their landed property.” It insists on their conforming to the laws and regulations that govern the municipality—meaning the obligations to pay taxes, etc.—and makes them amenable to the Ottoman civil tribunal in all questions relating to landed property, whether as plaintiff or defendant, without being able to avail themselves of their own consular court; except in those cases where immunity is attached to their persons and their movable goods, according to the treaties.

Article V of the same Iradé provides: "All foreigners shall enjoy the privileges of the present law as soon as the Powers on which they depend shall agree to the arrangement proposed by the Sublime Porte for the exercise of the right to hold real estate."

The United States government accepted this arrangement and issued a Protocol October 29, 1874, in which were added a number of stipulations that further favored American citizens. From this it is evident that foreigners are not amenable to the municipal laws of Turkey in matters relating to the person or movable property and they are amenable only in cases involving landed property.

Aside from the fact that Turkey, like all other Eastern countries, has special consular jurisdiction for the benefit of foreigners who are not under the jurisdiction of Turkish judicial authorities, no local law can affect an alien's right of residence in the absence of criminal charges against him. Mr. Freylinghuysen instructed Mr. Hamlin, minister to Spain, June 19, 1882, as follows: "The government will regard the imposition of taxes or charges in Cuba, discriminating against colored citizens of the United States on the ground of their color, as the subject of international complaint." Mr. Porter, acting Secretary of State, in his instructions to Mr. Emmet, minister to Turkey, June 8, 1883, declared: "Taxation may no doubt be imposed in conformity with the law of nations, by a sovereign, on the property within his jurisdiction, of a person who is domiciled in or owes allegiance to a foreign country. It is otherwise, however, as to a tax imposed not on such property, but on the person of the party taxed when elsewhere domiciled and elsewhere a citizen. Such a decree is internationally void." If a poll or b