this is insufficient to confer full citizenship, and to exempt him from being subject to all the laws of his native land should he return there; but it will, however, sustain an appeal to the good offices of the United States.
The case of Martin Koszta, the Hungarian patriot, is one in point. He came to this country in 1850 and declared, in legal form, his intention to become a citizen of the United States. He remained in the United States two years. Then he returned to Turkey and while at Smyrna was taken captive near that harbor by an Austrian brig of war. The United States legation at Constantinople interposed without effect. Commander Ingraham forced Koszta to be given over to the care of the French consulate at Smyrna, whence he was subsequently liberated. President Pierce, in his first Annual Message, 1853, said: "After a careful consideration of the case, I came to the conclusion that Koszta was seized without legal authority at Smyrna; that he was wrongfully detained on board of the Austrian brig of war; that at the time of the seizure, he was clothed with the nationality of the United States; and that the acts of the officers under the circumstances of the case were justifiable and their conduct has been fully approved by me and a compliance with the several demands of the Emperor of Austria cannot be granted."
Now, as to the right claimed by the Turkish government to discriminate against American citizens who profess the Jewish religion: Probably the first case recorded when official action was taken by the United States government, bearing on this phase of the subject, is that recorded in 1840, at the time when Jews were maltreated in Damascus. The legation at Constantinople was instructed by Secretary Forsyth "to interpose its good offices on behalf of the oppressed and persecuted Jews within the Ottoman dominions."
Again, in 1857, the United States consul joined the consuls of other nations in protest against the conviction of Jews in Morocco for blasphemy, in which he received the approval of his government. In his fourth Annual Message, 1880, President Hays informed Congress: "At the invitation of the Spanish government, a conference has been held at the city of Madrid to consider the subject of protection by foreign powers of native Moors in the Empire of Morocco. The minister of the United States in Spain was directed to take part in the deliberations of the conference. . . The government of the United States
has also lost no opportunity to urge upon the Emperor of Morocco the necessity, in accordance with the humane and enlightened spirit of the age, of putting an end to the persecutions which have been so prevalent in that country, of persons of a faith other than Moslem, and especially of the Hebrew residents of Morocco.”
Referring to a request by Mr. Isaacs of New York, dated June 4, 1877, "that protection be granted by the United States representatives in the Ottoman dominions to Israelites of Russian birth in and near Jerusalem," Mr. F. W. Seward, acting Secretary of State, said: "As a rule, our representatives abroad are permitted to extend the protection of the United States only to native-born or naturalized citizens thereof, but sympathy . . . for all oppressed peoples in foreign countries has been freely manifested. . . . In granting such protection it is requisite, of course, that the representatives of the country to which the persons requiring protection owe allegiance should request it, and the authorities of the country in which they are at the time residing, consent to it. . ." Evidently Mr. Seward did not understand that both the Russian and the Ottoman governments would be averse to permitting foreign protection, when they themselves could have given that protection if they were so disposed.
But with respect to American Jewish citizens, the State Department has always protested against any attempt to discriminate with regard to religious profession.
President Cleveland, in his first Annual Message, 1885, said: "Questions concerning our citizens in Turkey may be affected by the Porte's non-acquiescence in the right of expatriation and by the imposition of religion tests as a condition of residence, in which the government cannot concur. The United States must hold in their intercourse with every power, that the status of their citizens is to be respected and equal civil privileges accorded to them without regard to creed."
Secretary Bayard, also wrote to Mr. Cox, minister to Turkey, August 29, 1885: ". . .Friendship and international comity entitle the United States to ask and expect that no race or class distinction shall be made as regards American citizens abroad, and this government cannot acquiesce in any such prescriptive measures which compel its citizens to abandon Turkey solely on account of their religious proclivities."
The declarations of Mr. Cleveland and Mr. Bayard, quoted above, bear on the case reported
