"Die Welt" — No. 52.
(continued from page 6)
…half of the 'nineties I experienced, may also set in with respect to the present undertakings. I do not mean to assert by this that all work in Palestine is senseless or purposeless; only I do not see in it the real solution and the way to the attainment of our ideal. I reckon with the fact that the attainment of legal guarantees or of a charter before the onset of a mass colonisation has proved an impossibility, and that will hardly be otherwise in the near future. I do not, however, hold it to be absolutely impossible. I believe that, if a mighty organisation and colossal means were in our hands, we could after all attain it in the end.
But since the creation of such an organisation and of such means is not to be foreseen in the near future, in spite of all the work of past years, the nationalisation of the Jewish masses — not in the form of an abstract doctrine, but in the creation of concrete forms of life — appears as our direct task, and political activity in Russia, now that we in some measure possess the possibility of self-determination, as a question of our self-preservation.
B. Goldberg observes that one should not confine oneself to one political tendency. The main thing is that the Jewish people itself should be capable of defending its rights: better a minimum of rights in reality than a maximum on paper. In Galicia, for example, the Jews possess equal rights, but cannot enforce them, since they are unorganised. Let us first organise the people, so that later it may be able to protect its rights.
Dr. Tschlenow: I wish to set before you my standpoint, the standpoint of one with a long Zionist practice. I notice that we are falling into extremes. There is a tendency, for example, to regard as no Zionist the man who will not identify Zionism with practical work in Palestine. I myself am for practical activity in Palestine, but believe that this activity will become truly fruitful only after the attainment of legal guarantees.
Further, I see nothing new in the putting forward of the demand for work for the present. Ever since the Second Congress we have included in our programme first cultural, and afterwards economic work.
I expect miracles neither from a National Assembly nor from a national "Sejm"; but they can bring about an improvement in the economic and cultural life of our people, and for that reason they form part of our aims. I believe that a National Assembly will bring the political physiognomy of the Jewish people into the light and solve many national questions that have ripened. One thing more is important to me as a practical man: in the early period our organisation suffered from a want of living, everyday activity, — I am glad now that we can unite our forces on the ground of an everyday work that supplements our Zionist programme.
After Grünbaum, Pasmanik and Schabotinsky had then endeavoured to supplement or explain their earlier remarks, Mr. Seidenmann replied to the criticism of his report. He pointed to the characteristic fact that, although almost all the speakers had disputed the postulates of Grünbaum's address, all had nevertheless come to the conclusion that national work in the Diaspora is necessary and possible. From this he draws the conclusion that this question has become ripe for decision, and proposes that, after a thorough discussion of individual points of his report, the resolution drawn up by him be put to the vote.
A commission, to which the reporters Seidenmann and Grünbaum were also elected, thereupon brought in, in the course of the sitting, the following
Resolutions concerning the Political Platform of the Russian Zionists
which were also adopted by the conference:
Considering that the organisation of the Jewish people for national self-activity, according to the second point of the Basle Programme, appears as one of the most essential preconditions for the realisation of Zionism, inasmuch as it increases the forces of Jewry in the Diaspora and brings it new cultural, material and political means in the struggle for the creation of a normal national life in Palestine; considering further the circumstance that in the countries of the Diaspora the national organisations can develop only under the protection of the State, which is possible only under a democratic constitution of the State, — the Third Conference sanctions the entry, which has already taken place in a natural way, of the Zionist masses into the struggle for freedom of the territorial peoples of Russia, and holds it necessary to carry out the national union of Jewry on the ground of the transformation of the Russian State now in progress, for the purpose of securing the recognition of the Jewish nationality and of legal self-government in all matters of Jewish national life.
In consequence, the Zionist Organisation in Russia will advocate the following programme:
-
The democratisation of the Russian State on the basis of a consistent parliamentarism, a far-reaching political freedom, an autonomy of the national territories and the corresponding guarantees for the national minorities.
-
Complete and absolute equality of rights for the Jewish population.
-
The guarantee of the rights of minorities under universal, equal, direct and secret suffrage without distinction of sex, at all State, provincial and communal elections.
-
The recognition of the Jewish nationality as a whole, with the right of self-government in all affairs of national life.
-
The convocation of an All-Russian Jewish National Assembly for the working out of the foundations of a national organisation.
-
The right to use the national language in the courts, in the school and in public life.
-
The right of the Jews to keep the Sabbath rest instead of the Sunday rest.
Schabotinsky speaks in his own and Seidenmann's name on the question of immediate activity.
In his opinion the Jews, since they form neither quantitatively nor qualitatively a brilliantly outstanding force, can play no important part in the struggle for freedom. Therefore they should merely take part in the action of the decisive elements. But at the moment when the height of the cultural level and intellectual development come into consideration, we can play a more important part. Above all in the solution of the national questions and in the question of the construction of the State of nationalities we can have our say.
At first many among us believed, since we are a people without territory, that the other peoples of Russia too ought to solve their national questions territorially. But we are everywhere a minority and consequently cannot demand of the majorities that they should adapt themselves to us. Therefore we must demand: 1. A national autonomy for the territories with a homogeneous population. 2. The guarantee of the rights of the minorities. From this standpoint we can determine who our allies are. They are, for example, the Little Russians of Petersburg, the Poles in Volhynia, in the South-Western Territory, and so on. We must point out to these groups where their interests lie. We must therefore rely not upon the elements that sympathise with us, but upon such elements as pursue interests at one with ours. The indispensable precondition of such co-operation is a democratic policy. A league of such national minorities must stand up for the rights of the several peoples represented in it. Simultaneously with activity outwards, we must lay within Jewry a basis for the national organisation whose recognition by the State we intend to win in the political struggle. We must create the embryonic foundation of the future communities ipso facto and prepare the convocation of a National Assembly. All this work outside and within Jewry the Zionists should accomplish under their own banner as a Zionist party. One can and should enter into the closest connexion with kindred Jewish parties, but act in one's own name and under one's own flag. The same tactics we must pursue during the elections too; but, in order to avoid the danger of splitting the Jewish vote, the utmost caution is called for. In this case joint action with the Jewish Electoral Committee is advisable, whereby, however, we should retain the right to carry on an electoral propaganda in our own name and from our own standpoint up to the last electoral meeting, where we should unconditionally vote for the candidates of the majority list, even if these candidates are opponents of Zionism. The one exception should be the case where the majority elects an assimilationist.
These remarks of Schabotinsky's gave rise to a lively debate. The opposite standpoint was represented by Weißenberg, Motzkin, etc., who advocated the formation of a People's Party, consisting of Jewish Nationalists and Zionists. Mr. Weißen-