No. 52. — "Die Welt" — 3.
(continued from page 2)
…joined the party of the "Peaceful Renovators." We would not believe this news, and in this place we rejected it as absurd in the political and the ethical sense. A few days afterwards the "Society for the Attainment of Jewish Equal Rights in Russia" repudiated the report as invented for tendentious ends. The matter would thus be disposed of. But now similar reports are cropping up from other towns, and, what is worse still, they find admission and enthusiastic comment in West-European Jewish papers.
Once more, then: who are the Peaceful Renovators? Very comfortable gentlemen who, between the Chartreuse and the Upmann, allow themselves a sweet longing for reforms in Russia by way of dessert, Sunday sportsmen of the revolution. Peaceful they are, all reconciliation, all love, but the renovation is a figure of speech. One saw them already in the first Duma ... with their hesitating and their stinting, with their cowardly shirking, with their anxious wavering. Now "they draw near again, wavering forms," weak, inwardly brittle spirits, pussyfooters drowsing along in half-slumber, and announce a new campaign. With velvet paws they mean to bring down a mammoth. They seek the "moderate elements." Now, to be sure, not all Jews are radical stormers of the world. Nor do all Jews view the world from the angle of the class struggle. And the "Peaceful Renovators" have, by the skin of their teeth, adopted a resolution that all nationalities, and consequently the Jews too, are to have equal rights. It stands written on little slips of paper.
That the Jews should stand on their own feet and give their own feelings wider scope has been repeated to the point of satiety. That in the crass manifestations of over-excitement there must be unpleasant excrescences, every reasonable man understands. The unbridled hatred, the embittered enmity among the factions, groups and splinters of parties, each of which believes itself in sole possession of objective truth, no more represents the essence of events in Russia than, say, ulcers on a body represent the essence of a disease. But the simplicity on the Jewish side would be downright childish that sought to view the mighty world-drama now being played out in Russia from the standpoint of the "Peaceful Renovators." Whether they have really joined this party or not, the fact is that there exist in Russia specimens of a dying stratum of "notables" who think and say: the Jewish mass in its great majority is not revolutionary. They say and think so, the comfortable gentlemen, because they simply do not understand the word, do not understand that Russia is engaged in a process of transformation and that a reactionary phalanx, the whole tchinovnik caste with the Black cadres, is obstructing this process, that what is needed is a firm union of all progressive elements, and that accordingly the one task is and remains: the overcoming of what is outworn, rotten, decayed. The Jews may claim for themselves the undisputed right of having given their full strength to this process.
Now the "Peaceful Renovators" are not, to be sure, among the raven-black; they are, say, brunette. But this shade changes nothing. The programme may sound ever so reformatory: here Zola's phrase comes into its own: seen through another temperament. The programmes and the commonplaces have been written, printed and spoken a thousand times; they flutter away and dissolve into nothing. Against the bulwark of reaction these paper kites are child's play. Decision, manliness, the weight of energetic progress, the ruthless, and if need be even brutal, unrolling of the antagonisms: that is what makes the revolutionary. More than the men, it is the time: the crisis has reached its zenith, and there is no faint-hearted procrastination, no haggling policy called "horse-trading," no slackening, but an Either-Or. Herein the temper of an extraordinary time differs from everyday, normal tempers. Decades, nay centuries pass before such a temper takes shape as the product of all that has gone before, and it is naive to lay it at the door of the Jews or to try to brush it off their coat-tails.
The departing communal notables are right that the majority of the Jewish mass is not revolutionary. It is passive, like the majority of every mass, but that part does not count. The part that matters does not stand within the spell of the "Peaceful Renovators." One should not cavil at this; it is a natural necessity, the consequence of a thousand causes.
We are not among the optimists who regard the Russian process of transformation as the final solution of the Jewish question. This process may pave the way to a modus vivendi, an alleviation still bound up with great struggles. But neither the leathern bureaucrats nor the opportunist-conservative "Peaceful Renovators" will roll the mountain of exceptional laws off our backs. It is a work for men, for whole men, for strong men. And therefore the departure of any Jewish group to the party of the "Peaceful" would be a short-lived folly, a tragicomic intermezzo.
"Kolo polskie" The nationalist hotchpotch has come together in Poland. Enough hostile words have been exchanged; now it is: "Rabble quarrel, rabble make it up." For it is a matter of warding off a common danger, of warding off the onslaught of the strangers. National Democracy (N. D.) and the Polish Progressive Party (P. P. P.) both, it is true, still shrink from speaking out openly and confessing that at bottom they are of one heart and one soul; in reality, however, the whole purpose of the play that is still being acted on the stage of party life is empty show, calculated to deceive the uninitiated. Those in the know already stand together smiling like augurs and know only the one common concern for the integrity of the future "Kolo Polskie" (Polish Ring) in the Duma. So they describe their endeavour; in truth they have at heart only the sole dominion of the Polish Nationals, which as privileged persons they do not wish to forgo, whether they profess National Democracy or Polish "Progress." For they are united even in Warsaw, that is, where mutual jealousy had flared most fiercely. Sygietynski's compromise paper and the compromise-minded "Goniec" cannot find words enough when it comes to protesting against the imputation of antisemitic leanings. That is the catchword with which they seek to lure the credulous Jews into following them. But were not the National Democrats antisemitic through and through, and did they not at the last Duma elections agitate quite openly against the Jews with threats of pogroms? And how could a "Progressive Party" fuse with such reactionaries? Whoever might still be naive enough to believe in differences of principle between the "more" or "less" nationalist party formations has every opportunity to learn better if he looks at the Polish parties in their attitude, not to the abstraction of Jewish equal rights, but to the concrete matter of Jewish elections to the Duma, in the light of the latest occurrences in the preparations for the elections. Of hostility one feels precious little there, although there would truly have been no lack of combustible matter for a clash of antagonisms. The question of the Jewish mandates was one such occasion. For logically 6—7 Jews from Poland ought to be elected to the Duma. The National Democrats, who at the time of the first elections believed they ought to hold the Jews at arm's length, were of the opinion this time that they must make some small concession or other. It is so easy to see through these tactics. One would very much like some so-
