Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 51 · 21 December 1906
8printed page
scan 8 of 28

Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 51.

(continued from page 7)

…has shown the negative side of diplomacy. It has become clear that by this path alone we shall not attain Palestine, and that we must consequently look about us for another. Then the resistance broke loose which at length led to the outcome of the VIIth Congress and finally also to the resolution of the Helsingfors Conference concerning Palestine.

Out of these changes Zionism has returned to its origin, — to the so-called "Chibas-Zion". This word has in the last years become almost a term of mockery and abuse. It suffices to describe a Zionist as a "Chowew-Zion in disguise" in order, as it were, to stigmatise him. It is the fate of all parties, of all doctrines, to be outgrown by their own children. Social Democracy looks down with a pitying smile on pre-Marxian, "Utopian" Socialism. But to outgrow means only to go further, not to stand still. If in our case we consider the Chibas-Zion movement in its relation to Zionism, we see in the latter a further development, an elaboration of what was there only protoplasm. What did the Chibas-Zion want, then, other than Zionism, other than the final goal of our policy? Are not both paths, on this point, by no means distant from each other? Whence, then, the opposition? I should like to say that the opposition consists only in this, that Zionism is reluctant to recognise itself in the very modest forms of the old movement. Chowewe-Zionism was a movement for the few. It did not wish to solve the whole Jewish question. It did not perhaps venture to approach the great problems of Jewish existence. Certainly Smolenski was a Zionist in our sense of the word, although he was only a Chowew-Zion. But the means were still primitive. It was no movement; it was a dream.

What Zionism really created was not the idea — that was old —, not the will to independence, but the organisation. This mighty factor Zionism brought into Jewish life, precisely at a time when the old cement, when Jewish nationhood, was beginning to vanish. Zionism has begun to organise the masses of the people. And not in order to "proletarianise" them, as the "Bund" undertook to do. And not for alien, general purposes, but for their own national interests, for their great goal in the future. Zionism has restored the already shattered bridge between yesterday and to-morrow. If now the Chowewe-Zion of the old stamp, the incorrigibles, come and wish to fasten their method of individual activity, of slow polyp-like labour, upon the organising activity of the Zionists and thereby to paralyse it, then indignation is understandable. For by the method of the Chowewe-Zion, who do not regard the Jewish question as a whole, who see only one side of the question, every great, creative work would truly be paralysed. Chowewe-Zionism is the content, but political Zionism is the form. Just as "Charterism" as such is sterile, since it condemns us to a fruitless waiting, since it bars every outlet to the forces of the people, so Chowewe-Zionism in and of itself is not manifold enough to be able to meet all the needs of Jewish life. And "the needs of thy people are great", men lamented even in olden times. The return to Chowewe-Zionism would thus be only harmful, because no return to an outgrown idea can be of use. But persistence in the demand for unswerving Charterism would also be a step backward. I do not wish to refute Charterism "scientifically", as some did. Of that one got to hear a great deal at the Helsingfors Conference. If one were willing to take the words of many speakers, all too fond of philosophising, on trust, one would have to assume that, just as once, according to the theory of phrenology, a quite special place lay ready in the brain for every quality however small, so too in sociology there are for every sort of historical phenomenon their own "laws", made, as it were, specially for them. Thus I heard of "sociological laws" on the occasion of the Charter question, on the occasion of emigration, in respect of every question of Jewish policy that was broached. Perhaps there are such "laws". But with "laws" one can prove a great many things, and I should like only to tell the "law-abiding" a word of a French thinker on the concept of the causality of laws. "Eh bien", he said, "balayons la loi!" —. But we leave open the question whether Charterism is "scientifically" grounded or not, whether "catastrophic" Zionism, that is, the Zionism which takes its starting-point from the catastrophes of Jewish life and reckons on a catastrophe as the possibility of fulfilment, or "synthetic Zionism" is right. In sociological questions there is no firm Yes and no categorical No, no Must, but an Ought. But one thing is clear to us, that Zionism, with regard to its real goal, has now turned into a proper river-bed, and that there the unfolding of its energy will be made possible for it..

From the theory of "synthetic Zionism" the theoreticians of the Conference also deduced the necessity for the Zionist party to appear on the fencing-ground of internal Russian politics as a party of its own, "with its own flag" and its own political platform. This view was opposed by the opinion of a minority, who wished to keep Zionism away from the broad highway of general, all-devouring politics and broke a lance for the formation of a separate Jewish political party, the "People's Party". The Conference adopted the resolution of the "own flag". It was indeed right insofar as one does not found two parties when one can manage with one. If one is rich, one may build two or more houses. But one can live only in one house. And since the Zionists must once and for all descend into the political whirlpool of the present, it is better that they do so with visor raised.

But those who see in Zionism something other than a struggle of the moment, reckoned for the instant and passing with the instant, those who know the winding and dangerous paths of politics, see a danger peering out of the resolution. Where, then, is the line to be drawn between politics in the name of Zionism and politics for Zionism? And what if politics spreads itself wide, becoming itself end and means? In this widening of Zionism lies hidden also the danger of its losing itself in the distance.

The resolution of the Conference is, however, only a confirmation, a sanctioning of what has already happened. The Zionists are in any case already up to their ears in internal Russian politics. The contrary would be an impossibility, nay, an absurdity. Zionism is a philosophy of Jewish life, but "primum vivere, deinde philosophari". However pessimistic one may be about the future of the Jews in Russia, the struggle for this future must interest in the liveliest degree every Jew who lives in Russia. But of what kind is the struggle to be? To which category of those in Russia who want things otherwise can the Jews, or rather the organised part of the national Jews, the Zionists, attach themselves? To their own, — answered the Conference. But will they, as an independent political party, be strong enough even in the Jewish street alone? We shall soon see. The elections for the Duma are drawing near, and we shall be able to see from the passage of arms to whom the first place in Jewry belongs. Unless all signs deceive, the Zionists will this time, too, come off with the first prize. And that not with the help of their political platform. For this is still rudimentary; it is still theory, still pure idea. No political programme is born like the foam of the sea, arisen all at once in perfection. The programme presupposes a thorough-going democratisation, a fundamental reform of Russia. When will that come?