Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 51 · 21 December 1906
2printed page
scan 5 of 28

No. 51. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.

(continued from page 4)

…this is not accomplished merely, as Goldberg thinks, by our buying only land in Palestine with the moneys of the National Fund; we must also call into being from these means institutions that contribute to the development of the country. I need only recall the cotton plantations, the Bezalel, which will introduce a new industry rich in promise into Palestine, the co-operative settlements on the Oppenheimer plan, etc. I do not share Kremenetzky's fears. The National Fund is no fetish that may not be touched. It is accumulated energy; we must make this energy liquid. But the work in Palestine requires money, — and the means are lacking. The Palestine Commission is without means. Things cannot go on like this. We must think of instituting a special Palestine shekel, which would procure the means for the work. For the political work in Palestine, too, a fund — a political fund — is necessary.

It is often complained that the work in Palestine meets with no responsiveness on the part of the Inner A.C. That is understandable, too, since the I.A.C. is composed of quite heterogeneous elements. The A.C. must be unified and must receive directives from the Congress. These directives, however, can already by our conference prepared is, to undertake. The Basle Programme must remain untouched and unaltered, a still pole amid the flight of appearances. We have no need of it, since among us, as regards the work in Palestine, there exist almost no differences of opinion, as there do in the West. We must make our programme precise and agitate for it. He further recalls the Neu-Biluj, — the so-called Palestine pioneers, and greets their devoted activity.

Kaharlitzky opposes the view of Goldberg and Pasmanik that the National Fund could be used at once. The National Fund, he says, must not be employed before its legalisation.

Tschlenow gives information on the present state of the legalisation of the National Fund. The land purchases of the National Fund, he says, are to a certain extent secured, even though the National Fund is no juridical person in Turkey.

Rubinow expresses his regret that the labour question in Palestine is wholly ignored. We must organise the human material already present in Palestine. The workers who come to Palestine live in great distress. They must often leave the country, and those who leave it become embittered against the country. That must now be changed. We must give the

Hebrew instruction at the Bezalel

be. And therefore we must accept a unified programme. We could deduce the practical work in Palestine from the Basle Programme, but it is not necessary. Zionism is an objective necessity, a system that must pass through an immanent development. And it is upon this development that everything now depends. I should like to apply to our movement, too, the saying: "The goal is nothing, the movement is everything!" (Lively applause.)

Bregman proposes that Goldberg's report be published in Hebrew, Russian and German. He opposes the introduction of the Palestine shekel advocated by the previous speaker. It would be more expedient to raise the amount of the ordinary shekel. As regards the political work, almost nothing is being done in this respect on the part of the Inner A. C. We must at least demand of it that it send a representative to Constantinople. He further pleads for the most intensive work in Palestine and holds that the proposal to found a Palestine Commission in Palestine itself must be accepted, since that is of the highest importance.

Tschlenow objects to the attempt to bind the leading bodies by giving concrete form to certain wishes. The Conference, he says, must not seek to commit the A.C. to this or that action before the decision of the Congress.

Dreisenstock: We have no need at all, a supplement to the Basle Programme such as is perhaps desired by Dr. Pasmanik workers the opportunity to settle in Palestine and to be able to live there.

Goldenberg: We are not competent to enter into the special questions that have been dealt with in Goldberg's report. Our business is the examination of principles, of the question: Well, what has been done for Palestine in the last four years? This question we must discuss. And we shall arrive at a sad result.

Weißenberg is of the opinion that the question of representation in Constantinople cannot be decided over the heads of our western fellow Zionists. As for the proposal concerning the agrarian bank in Palestine, it is premature. Goldberg is wrong in maintaining the view that we should promote only agriculture in Palestine and leave the development of urban industry outside the sphere of our activity. Who, then, could foresee the path that life in Palestine will take? Palestine may just as well become an agricultural as an industrial and commercial State. Our business is only to create a home secured by public law, — the rest we must leave to the future. Dr. Pasmanuk complained of the disunity in the I. A. C. and demands a unified A. C. But where in all the world has there ever been a wholly unified Cabinet? Not even in England, where the Cabinet is always the ministry of the victorious party, no, not even in Russia ...

Babkow: One has here for us an opposition between con-

2