"Die Welt" — Page 4. — No. 51.
(continued from page 3)
…and Djiftlik lands, be achieved. By steps in Constantinople a concession in this direction might be obtained. The second obstacle is formed by the system of taxation in Turkey, the so-called Oscher, that is, 12 1/2 % of the harvest. The practice of the Turkish officials has made this impost an intolerable burden for the husbandmen. In Macedonia the Sultan, thanks to the pressure of the European Powers, has introduced a new system of taxation, namely the levy by the Dynam. Government circles in Constantinople are inclined to extend this system to the remaining territories of Turkey as well, in order to lessen their dependence on Europe. It would, for example, be possible to farm the whole Oscher of all the Palestinian colonies, whereby a burden would be lifted from the colonies. But for this, energetic, systematic work by competent men in Constantinople is required. The lack of such suitable men on the spot has evidently already caused us to miss many a favourable opportunity. We must have diplomatic agents in Constantinople. And I should like to recommend the following resolution to the Conference:
That it be proposed to the Inner A.-C. to set up a representation in Constantinople even before the Congress, whether in the form of an agent of the Anglo-Palestine Bank, or of a confidential agent of the colonists, or in any other form.
We said, however, that the aim of practical work in Palestine is the creation of normal conditions for Jewish activity in Palestine. One of these conditions is the creation of a mortgage credit for the purchase of houses and land. No country can thrive under present conditions without this institution. In Russia alone mortgage credit amounts to more than two milliards of roubles. Egypt, Palestine's nearest neighbour, which under the administration of the English has made giant strides in modernisation and amelioration, owes its success in the agricultural field in great part to the introduction of mortgage credit. Since the year 1881 there has existed there a mortgage bank with a share capital to the amount of 25 million frcs., which has already issued debentures for 183 millions. Its shares, whose nominal value is 125 frcs., are quoted on the Bourse at 710 frcs. From the importance of mortgage credit, the significance and the necessity of the Agrarian Bank are self-evident. And it is in the urgent interest of the Zionist Organisation to recognise in principle the necessity of this institution and to accept the proposal of Prof. Warburg, which is to appoint a special commission of Zionists, or of other Russian Jews as well, to work out the plan for the realisation of this indispensable institution. This commission would be charged with the study of the possibilities of obtaining a concession for the founding of an Agrarian Bank with mortgage rights under the existing conditions in Turkey, and also with the technical financial aspects of the question. The founding of an Agrarian Bank ought also to be welcomed by the Western, so-called political Zionists, since it would be the union of practical work with political action; for an Agrarian Bank without sanction in public law on the part of the Turkish Government is unthinkable. Thus every objection of the extreme political Zionists would be disposed of in advance.
But the guarantee of success in Palestine lies in private enterprise. The more technicians, engineers and industrialists, who now in the Pale of Settlement live off one another, turn their labour and their capital to account in Palestine, the more rapidly will the upswing of the country proceed. Our task in this respect is to support and to further private initiative. To this end I propose the founding of a special Information Bureau attached to the Central Bureau in Russia or to the Palestine Commission, which shall undertake the supplying of information about Palestine. We also welcome every private undertaking that arises in Palestine.
We have, of course, cultural tasks to fulfil in Palestine as well. A new generation is growing up whose education lies close to our hearts.
I close my report with the words of an old connoisseur of Palestine and labourer in it: "I come more and more to the conviction that it is not external circumstances which prevent us from becoming the masters of Palestine, but the lack of interest in Zion in our people itself." ... My friends, our cause depends on ourselves; we can help it to victory; let us show ourselves worthy of our historic task! (Lively applause.)
Debates.
Dr. Tschlenow, following upon the speaker's remarks, draws attention to Prof. Warburg's concrete proposals concerning the work in Palestine and expresses the hope that the discussion will keep within the bounds of real and positive proposals.
Bregman (on the order of the day) suggests that Goldberg's report be handed over to a committee which shall formulate the theses and submit them to the Conference.
The first to enter the debate was Dr. D. Pasmanik. He said: "We must clarify in principle our relation to practical work in Palestine and its place within Zionism. I shall first formulate my resolution, which will serve as the leitmotif of my further remarks. It reads: In view of the fact that all State colonisation proceeds systematically, that Zionism is a process of evolution and must accordingly strive for a systematic State colonisation, the Party Conference resolves to use all means, including those of the National Fund, for the acquisition of land in Palestine; further, the necessity of obtaining concessions in Palestine by means of negotiations with the Turkish Government; the co-ordination of the work in Palestine with the rest of Zionist activity, namely through the recognition of the Palestine Commission as an integral part of the A. C. — And now to the grounds of my resolution. The question of practical work in Palestine is treated in the West from a different point of view than in Russia. In the West there are two views on this question. The one is that of the Charterists, who stand for the prior creation of guarantees in public law. The others take the standpoint of the evolutionary character of Zionism. In Russia opinions on this question are divided in another direction. The one side holds the work in Palestine to be only a form of the accumulation of energy in Russia itself, only a part of the party work; the others put it forward as the fundamental motive of all Zionist activity whatever ... Now to the Charterists. The concept of the Charter is handled among us very unclearly. Some hold the Charter to be a concession merely greater in quantity. But Charter and concession are two qualitatively different things. A concession is merely a compact between two parties; a Charter requires in addition the element of a guarantee on the part of a third party not directly concerned.
We can best illustrate this difference by the example of the Borneo Company. The society which formed the Borneo Company obtained sovereign rights from the Sultan of Borneo, that is, the right over the life and death of the inhabitants of the island. Yet the compact between the Company and the Sultan bore the character of a concession until, through the securing of a guarantee on the part of the British Government, it became a Charter. The Charter, then, requires three parties: the contracting parties and the guaranteeing party.
Herzl asked of the Sultan only a concession and no Charter properly so called. Could he have done otherwise? Can we, then, hope for a Charter in Palestine? So long as the Jews do not form a real power in Palestine, we shall never be able to obtain a Charter, at most a larger concession. Consequently we must recognise that we must ceaselessly continue our work in Palestine. This work in Palestine will in its turn also influence the energy of the Jews living in the Diaspora. This interaction leads us to the second question we have raised: Is the work in Palestine a leitmotif, or only a result? Those who hold that it is only a result, that is, something not directly willed, are inconsistent. They speak of the general accumulation of energy in the Diaspora. But where, then, are the limits? They speak of the theory of the Renaissance. No, the Jewish people is not in the stage of renaissance but of decadence; it is degenerating. We cannot speak of a development in the Diaspora, and therefore the work in Palestine must become an end in itself, a leitmotif. The work in the Diaspora can serve only as a spring-board. ... I have spoken of the necessity of systematic colonisation. That is not to say that we should open an artificial colonisation. No colonisation can thrive unless it springs from the needs of the people itself. An example of this is the colonisation of Tunis. The French Government employed every means to have the country settled by Frenchmen, but its efforts led to nothing, since the Frenchman, by virtue of his economic situation, is not compelled to emigrate; the Italian Government has not stirred a finger in the matter, but the Italian masses must emigrate, and in the course of a few years Tunis has become overfilled with Italian settlers. A colonisation policy must indeed aim at 'creating conditions, not things.' And therefore it cannot be our task to assist individual immigrants in Palestine, but to create the preconditions necessary for immigration. ... And
